Skip to content
Zoey, the Knowledge Keeper of the Pack, outside the reading room

01 · START

Only a confident mother

What kind of mother a puppy has shapes him before you ever meet him. Two first litters on the hill, a mother who ran and a mother who chose her place two days early, and what that means for the family who will take one of her puppies home.

  • 18 min read
  • 13 figures
  • Free to read
Text
Early morning on a dry hillside. Under a big rock is a hollow with a narrow opening, and a lean fawn mother dog lies across the mouth of it with her head up, watching the slope, while two dogs of her pack rest a long way off in the scrub.

At this age before birth

  • a dog is pregnant for about nine weeks
  • half of what a puppy is born with comes from his mother, and nearly everything he learns in his first eight weeks comes from her and his litter
  • heavy stress on a mother while she is pregnant is linked to puppies who are more fearful and cope less well with stress later
  • in a wild pack, as a rule, only one female has puppies, and she is the most confident one

One morning this October I woke up early and saw one of our young females licking herself behind. She was about to have her first litter. There was a thread hanging from her, the kind you see after a puppy has come out. But there was no puppy anywhere.

Then she ran. And the whole pack went after her: the females, the males, everyone. They surrounded her and kept trying to hold her in one place. At that moment I did not understand what they were doing. When I got to her, the next puppy was coming out, and she was still running with it hanging behind her. It fell, and I caught it.

Ink and wash of a dusty open yard on a hillside at dawn. A young fawn female dog runs with her ears flat and her tail tucked, and four other dogs of different colours crowd round her from both sides. Behind them a man in a dark T-shirt and track pants is hurrying across the yard toward her., open the figure larger
The morning she ran. A first-time mother who did not understand what was happening in her own body, and a pack trying to hold her in one place.

She had no idea what was happening to her. I picked her up, with the puppy, and carried her to the place we had made ready for her. Then I sat with her for a long time, about an hour and a half, keeping her company and reassuring her.

The puppies kept coming, and she did not know what they were or what to do with them. She would smell one and flinch away from it. I was frightened of what she might do. Then a puppy was put at her belly, and it started to drink. That felt good to her, and she began to calm down. Slowly, something started to form between her and them.

Ink and wash of a corner of a concrete room with old blankets on the floor. A young fawn mother dog lies stiffly with her head pulled back and away from a tiny wet newborn puppy lying near her belly. A man sits cross-legged right beside her, one hand resting still on her shoulder., open the figure larger
She flinched. A mother smelling her own newborn as if it were something strange, and a man sitting quietly beside her.
Ink and wash close study of a woman's hands placing a newborn puppy with sealed eyes against a lying mother dog's belly. The puppy has found a teat and is drinking. The mother's head has come down onto the blanket, and her ears have softened., open the figure larger
The first drink. A puppy put to her belly, and the first time her body tells her that this is good.

That was the morning. In the evening I went out to bring back the bowls of a dog I feed down at the farmhouse below us. On the way back I heard a puppy crying, from behind a cement sheet leaning against a wall. I went round it, and there was a newborn puppy, trying to dig its way out.

She had already given birth once that morning, outside, before any of us knew. That was the thread I had seen. The puppy had been lying there from morning till evening, crying, and nobody knew. One of our other females was sitting next to it. I took it in, put it with its mother, and now she had four.

Ink and wash of the end of a day on a hillside. A grey cement sheet leans against a low wall. A man holding two steel dog bowls bends to lift its edge, and under it a tiny newborn puppy lies with its mouth open, crying. An older brown female dog sits beside the sheet, looking at him., open the figure larger
Under the sheet. A puppy born outside before anyone knew, crying from morning till evening, with another female of the pack sitting beside it.

The other mother

That same year another of our females had her first litter, and she did everything differently.

She had found her spot well in advance. She had decided where it would be, how it would be, where the puppies would come, and she had gone and settled there two days before. When the time came, she did not run anywhere. She made her den with an opening so small that she could guard it with her mouth, and nobody could get in. For two months she did not leave her puppies. At the slightest sound she came running. She decided how far away the pack must stay and how close it could come, and she fought for that. None of the other mothers did anything like it.

Ink and wash of a dry slope with scrub and boulders. At the foot of a big rock a heavily pregnant fawn female dog lies in a shallow hollow she has dug, her belly round, her head resting on her paws, eyes open and calm. Fresh earth is pushed out in a fan in front of the hollow., open the figure larger
Two days early. A mother who has chosen her place and settled into it before the first puppy comes.
Ink and wash of a den dug under a rock, its opening barely wider than a dog's head. The fawn mother lies across the opening with her head up and her ears forward. A few metres away a large black male dog has stopped in his tracks and is turning his head aside. Behind the mother, in the dark of the den, two small puppies' faces can just be seen., open the figure larger
The narrow door. A den she can guard with her mouth, and a pack that comes only as close as she allows.

With her we did not have to do anything. There was zero intervention. With the first mother we had to step in again and again, and we still have to. She comes to her puppies now and then, as if it were a duty, and then she goes off and stays on her own. Her puppies are healthy, but if we had not been there, I do not think they would have lived.

There is a difference between mother and mother. Both were first-time mothers. And here is the thing that surprised me. The one who became the most responsible mother I have ever seen was the most wild of all our dogs, a hunter. I had worried about her more than any of them. She turned out to be the opposite of everything I feared.

Why nature lets only a confident mother breed

Afterwards I kept thinking about it. Why does it work like this?

Watch a pack of wild dogs, the primal ones. In a wild pack, as a rule, only one female becomes a mother: the confident one who leads. The others do not breed. If another female wants puppies, she has to leave and make a pack of her own. If our frightened young mother had lived in a pack like that, I do not think she would ever have become a mother.

Ink and wash of a wide rocky ridge at evening. Near a den at the foot of a boulder, one lean female dog stands with three small puppies around her legs. Around her, spread out across the ridge at a distance, five other dogs of the pack lie or stand facing outward., open the figure larger
Only the leader. In a wild pack, the one female with puppies is the most confident one, and the rest of the pack lives around her den.

The way I see it, there is a reason. When puppies come out of a mother, they bring something with them she has never felt before: a discomfort, a strangeness, a kind of fear. And when a dog meets something unfamiliar, she goes one of two ways. She goes towards curiosity, or she goes towards flight. A dog with low confidence goes towards flight. She may run, and she may leave her puppies. Fear can take over instinct.

A confident dog meets the same strange thing and gets curious about it. She smells it, she licks it, she stays. Only a dog with a certain amount of confidence in her can be curious at a moment like that.

Two drawn panels. In the first, a fawn mother dog lies with her neck stretched forward, sniffing a newborn puppy on the ground in front of her, her ears up and her body loose. In the second, a different young female dog is backing away from a newborn puppy on the ground, her head low, her ears flat and her tail tucked between her legs., open the figure larger
Curious, or gone. The same strange moment, met by a confident mother and by a frightened one.

So nature made a system. If fear comes, these dogs run, and if a mother runs, how will her puppies survive? Only the confident ones have puppies, and so only the confident ones pass themselves on.

The instinct to mother is very old. Earlier this year, in June, another of our females had her first litter in a corner of a room I had cleared for her, and I watched her do things nobody had ever taught her. You will see some of them in the next two chapters. But having the instinct in you is one thing. Being steady enough to follow it, while your own body is doing something it has never done before, is another. Not every female has that, and having puppies does not give it to her.

Any dog can have puppies now

That system is gone for our dogs. With dogs who live among people, any female can mate and get pregnant, confident or not. And having puppies does not mean she will look after them.

Ink and wash of a narrow Indian lane at dusk. A thin young female dog, visibly pregnant, has squeezed herself under a parked scooter beside a drain, her eyes wide and her ears back, while people walk past and a bicycle rings by., open the figure larger
Any female, anywhere. Among people, a frightened young female can have a litter as easily as the leader of a pack.

And then there are the mothers people breed for selling. In a puppy mill, a female lives her whole life in one cage, and she gives birth in it, again and again. In India most breeding happens in somebody's backyard. Very few breeders here will tell you anything about the temperament of the mother and the father.

Ink and wash of a dim shed with a row of small wire cages on a concrete floor. In the nearest cage a thin mother dog lies on bare wire with four small puppies against her, her head low, her eyes dull, looking out through the bars. A single bare bulb hangs above., open the figure larger
Born in a cage. A mother who has lived her whole life in one small space, and gives birth in it.

What she passes on

So what does a mother like this give to her puppies?

Some of it comes in the blood. Dogs carry genes, and the chance that something shows up in a puppy goes up with what his mother and father carry. A mother with a strong prey drive is more likely to have puppies with strong guarding and hunting drives. More likely, not certain. A gene test can tell you something about his body, but if I want to know his mind, I look at his parents. And how he lives, everything around him, plays the biggest part, eighty or ninety per cent of it. The first part of everything around him is her.

It starts before he is born. Research on dogs and on other animals has found that when a pregnant mother is under heavy stress, her puppies are more likely to grow up fearful and reactive, and less able to cope with stress. The thinking is that her stress hormones reach the puppies and set their own stress system. A lot of that detail comes from studies on rats and mice, not dogs, so it is not settled science for dogs. But it points the same way as everything else in this chapter.

Two drawn panels. In the first, a pregnant fawn dog sleeps on her side in the shade of a neem tree in a quiet courtyard, her round belly rising. In the second, a pregnant dog runs low and fast along a road beside a building site, a cement mixer turning behind her and a man waving a stick., open the figure larger
Two pregnancies. One mother carries her puppies in a quiet place, the other through noise and being chased. What she lives through reaches them too.

Then she gives birth, and what she is shows in every hour after that. A mother who flinches from her puppies, who wanders off, who comes back only to feed them, is still their mother. She is what they first learn the world from. A mother who settles, who stays, who decides how close the others can come and holds that line, is teaching them something else from their first day: that this place is safe, because she is not afraid in it.

His mother
Chooses her place before the puppies come, stays with them, and decides how close anyone may come.
What most of us do
Think a mother is a mother, and that her puppies come out the same whatever she is like.
What you do
Before you take a puppy, look at his mother. If your own dog is pregnant, give her a quiet place of her own and leave her in it.

If your own dog is pregnant

Some of you will have a pregnant dog at home. First, a vet confirms it. Some females go through a false pregnancy, with many of the same signs, and only a vet can tell you for sure.

Then make her a den: a secluded, safe place in a quiet corner of the house, with no one walking through it. When she is resting there, nobody walks straight up to her. As the birth gets close she will start protecting that place and making it ready. She may not let other dogs near it, and that is normal. Pregnancy is hard on a dog. Her body goes through many changes, and it makes her more territorial.

Ink and wash of a quiet corner of an Indian flat. Under a low wooden table draped with an old bedsheet, a pregnant fawn dog lies on folded blankets, her eyes half closed. In the foreground a woman in a mustard kurta walks past carrying a steel tumbler, looking ahead and not at the dog., open the figure larger
Her place, not ours. A pregnant dog resting in a den in a quiet corner, and a family who walk past without walking up to her.

Keep her days steady, and keep yourself calm around her. She reads you. A house that fusses over her, worried and excited, every time she lies down, is adding to what she is carrying. If she is a confident dog, she will need very little from you; the best thing you can do is stay out of her way. If she is a nervous one, she may need you near her, quiet and calm, the way that young mother on the hill needed us.

And if she is in labour and straining for a long time with no puppy coming, or she seems unwell, call a vet. Do not wait to see.

What this means when he is yours

Most of you reading this will not have a litter at home. You will go somewhere and bring a puppy back. So why does any of this matter to you?

Because the puppy you take home has already had a mother, and he has already been shaped by her. Some of it came in the blood. Some of it came in the nine weeks inside her. All of it came in the weeks after, because she was the whole world he knew.

So if you can, look at her. Not at the puppies first: at her. Look at the people around her too: how they keep their dogs, how the dogs are with them, whether they seem calm to you or tense.

Ink and wash of the gate of a small house with a cement yard. A woman in a mustard kurta and her husband in a grey-blue T-shirt stand just outside the gate, hands at their sides, looking in. In the yard a fawn mother dog stands steady in front of a doorway, ears up, looking straight back at them, while three puppies about seven weeks old tumble behind her., open the figure larger
Meet her first. A family at a gate, looking at the mother before they look at the puppies.

The way I look at a mother is simple. Can she settle? Does she stay with her puppies, or keep going off? When you arrive, does she watch you and hold her ground, or does she shake, hide, or run? A mother who keeps you at a distance from her puppies is not a bad sign. That may be exactly the mother you want.

You cannot change who his mother was. But knowing her tells you what he started with, and what he started with is what you will be working with.

The assignment

  • If you are going to choose a puppy. Ask to see his mother. Spend ten quiet minutes just watching her before you look at the puppies. Write down what she did when you arrived.
  • Watch what she does, not how she looks. Does she settle? Does she stay with them? Does she decide how close you come? Her coat and colour tell you nothing about this.
  • Look at the people too. How do they keep their dogs, and how are the dogs with them? Do they seem calm to you?
  • If your own dog is pregnant. A vet confirms it first. Then give her a quiet den in a corner nobody walks through, keep her days steady, and nobody walks straight up to her while she rests there.
  • Whoever you are. The next time you see a mother dog with her puppies, watch her from a distance for five minutes. Where did she choose? How close does she let other dogs come?

What she is, he starts out with. What she does with him in his first three weeks comes next, and it reaches him through the only doors he has when he is born. That is chapter 2: born with a nose and a face.

That is the end of chapter 01.

01. Only a confident mother | Before he's yours | OhMyDog.Rocks