Pro group call · Sun 2 Aug 2026 · 1 hr 16 min
The behaviorist lens: instincts, personality and trigger stacking
Sunny Luthra gave batch one and two members a revision overview of Modules 1 and 2, covering the behaviorist lens's four layers (animal, species, breed, personality), how dogs perceive reality mainly through touch and smell before sight and sound, and how associative based thinking is driven by emotional intensity and repetition. He explained how unmet breed instincts and unstable environments cause fear, anxiety, aggression and reactivity, and answered member questions on breaking instincts, walking nervous dogs, and handling trigger stacking on walks. The call closed with logistics on exam slots and community resources for the Pro certification.
Key points (6)
- Sunny explained the four layers of the behaviorist lens: animal, species, breed and personality.
- Dogs experience reality primarily through touch and smell before sight and sound, so calmer handling means talking less and letting the dog use its nose.
- Associative based thinking is shaped by two factors, the intensity of emotion and the number of repetitions, and can be used to build or break any habit.
- Unmet breed instincts, like a German Shepherd's herding drive, surface as behavioral issues such as ankle nipping, and indie dogs are hardest to diagnose because their breed mix is unknown.
- Individual personality and emotional baseline are the smallest layer but the one owners overweight, while environment shapes most of a dog's habits.
- Trigger stacking on walks should be broken early by stopping, turning the dog's back to the trigger, and waiting calmly before moving forward again.
- On the call
- Sunny, Kashish, Prafull, and 3 other voices
The behaviorist lens: instincts, personality and trigger stacking
0:00 / 1:15:53
Transcript
Hindi written in English letters. The audio is the record.
Speaker 1
Haan ji. Kaise chal rahi taiyari guys batch one?
Sunny
Tumhari aawaaz nahi aa rahi Kashish mute ho.
Speaker 1
Good.
Sunny
Okay. Aawaaz nahi aa rahi, aawaaz nahi aa rahi. Manya tumhara call tha, aaj toh Manya nahi.
Speaker 1
Yes, actually main bhool gayi ki aaj second of August hai. miss ho gaya mujhse.
Sunny
Kaun sa August hai?
Speaker 1
Second ka.
Sunny
Okay.
Speaker 1
Is there any chance we can reschedule the call?
Sunny
Haan, haan, bilkul.
Speaker 1
Okay. Aap mujhe batana. Yeah, sure.
Sunny
Yeah cool hai. So batate hain tumko, hai na? Toh aaj chalo log aa rahe hain abhi, aane dete hain. Phir start kar lete hain. Ek do minute abhi aa rahe hain. Kyunki aaj important cheez hai. Main aapko overview dene wala hoon module one ka and module two ka.
So jo log already go through ho chuke hain, unke liye ek revision type hai aur jo batch one hai, I think abhi teen log hain isme batch one ke, so unke liye ek overview mil jayega unko. Okay? So yeah all are present, I think so.
Please apna video on kar lijiyega taaki mere ko samajh mein aaye ki aap logon ko samajh mein aa raha hai aapki shakal dekhkar, shakal dekhkar. Let's start. Okay.
Speaker 1
Recording start ho raha hai?
Sunny
Yeah, recording start hai. So guys, abhi na main aapko do modules ka shuruat ke jo do modules hain, bahut important module hai aur abhi tak wahi open hai.
Isme chhah modules hain poore course ke andar, lekin right now aur aakhiri ke do module is like from a business and self development perspective hai, lekin dog ke perspective se shuruat ke chaar module bahut zyada important hai aapke liye. Aur aaj hum do module ke baare mein baat karne wale hain.
Jo naye batch ke students hain, unke liye ek overview mil jayega jab aap apni journey start karein courses dekhne ki. Plus jinke exams aa rahe hain batch one ke aur unko aapko thodi help mil jayegi taaki jo sawaal honge wo is par related honge. Obviously module one and module two se related hai.
So aaj hum behaviorist lens ke baare mein baat karne wale hain. Idhar se noise aa rahi hai. Puluska ji, aapka mic mute karenge. Abhi theek hai?
Yeah, got it. Yeah, idhar se aa rahi thi.
Speaker 3
Sunny mere paas ek request bhi hai.
Sunny
Aaj hum... kya bolna hai bataiye.
Speaker 3
Sunny request ye hai ki batch one ke liye jaise wo revision karte hue wo chhote-chhote questions nahi poochhte, aap humse poochhna. Humara, humara revision hoga.
Sunny
Toh tumhe pehle main usse achha teacher banta hoon. Tumhe pehle waapas se padha raha hoon main. Hai na? Uske baad poochhenge. Hai na? Uske baad poochhenge. So, toh first, first thing hum aaj kya padhne wale hain? Aaj kya samajhne wale hain? Behaviorist lens ke baare mein samjhenge.
Hum dog as a species ke baare mein samjhenge. Dog kaise apni reality ko experience karta hai uske senses ke dwara. Association based thinking kya hoti hai? Dog mein social structure aur stability kaise aati hai?
Jo breeds hoti hai dog ki, wo kaise unke behavior ko shape karta hai? Instincts kaise unke shape karte hain? Wo kaise apne behavior ke jo instincts hote hain, unko express karte hain, uske baare mein baat karenge.
And then phir hum uske baare mein baat karenge har ek dog ki ek individual personality bhi hoti hai, jo generally log sirf usi par dhyan dete hain. But wo ek upper ki layer hai, hum uske baare mein baat karenge.
Then uske baare mein hum uske baad baat karenge ki body language se kaise communicate karte hain, energy se kaise communicate, communicate karte hain, signal se kaise communicate karte hain, jisse dog effectively aapko understand kar pata hai.
Aur aakhir mein last wale point mein main aapko saare issues ka combination doonga, like fear kya hota hai? Anxiety kya hoti hai? Frustration kya hota hai? Aggression kya hota hai? Reactivity kya hoti hai? Okay. So let's, let's start from this thing ki behaviorist ka ek lens kya hota hai?
So hum kabhi bhi dog ko, ek behaviorist dog ko kaise observe karta hai? For example, log kaise observe karte hain, bhai ye dog hai ya phir ye Rottweiler hai ya phir ye Pitbull hai ya phir ye mera buddy hai aur ye is tareeke ka hi hai. Aur bahut se trainers bhi is tareeke se hi dog ko like analyze karte hain.
Wo kai baar ho sakta hai dog ki breed ko analyze kar rahe ho ya phir dog ki personality ko analyze kar rahe ho. Lekin dog different layers hoti hai. So dog ki pehli layer hoti hai, ek wo ek animal hai. Okay, behaviorist ka lens kya, lens kaise dekhta hai? Sabse pehle wo uske andar ke ek animal ko dekhta hai. Okay?
Aage jaakar aapko samajh mein aayega ki kya matlab hota hai animal ka. Lekin behaviorist ka lens kya hota hai? Sabse pehle wo dog ko ek animal ki tarah dekhta hai. Doosra, wo dog ko ek species ki tarah dekhta hai.
Yaani wo ek dog hai. Hai na? Dog ka ek apna tareeka hai jeene ka. Animal ka apna ek tareeka hai jeene ka. Teesri hota hai ki uski breed kya hai. Breed ka apna ek expression hota hai. Like wo apne aap ko kaise express karte hain. Har ek breed ka apna ek expression hota hai. Aur chauthi cheez hoti hai personality.
So ye chaar layer hoti hai. Jis tareeke se hum dog ko dekha karte hain, ek behaviorist dekhta hai aur general public ya general jo bhi log jinko psychology ke baare mein understanding nahi hai, wo sirf breed tak hi jaate hain, ki ye breed aisi hoti hai. Wo animal tak nahi utarte, wo species tak nahi utarte.
So ek behaviorist ka lens, ye overview kya hai is, is, is topic ka? Humein dog ko ek animal ki tarah dekhna hota hai. Uske baad, uske baad, uske saath-saath nahi, uske baad, ek animal ko dekhne ke baad, uske baad humein dekhna hota hai ki wo uski jo species hai, jo wo dog hai, wo, wo kya hai?
Hai na? Uska kis tareeke ka zindagi jeene ka tareeka hai? For example, animal ka kya hota hai? Animal likes freedom. Animal ko kya chahiye? Animal ko freedom chahiye, animal ko safety chahiye. Freedom ka matlab, safety ka matlab kya hota hai? Like hum usko shelter de rahe hain. Hum usko khaane ka de rahe hain.
Hum usko time par ye sab cheezein de rahe hain. Plus hum usko ek safe environment, hum usko ek safe environment provide kar rahe hain. That is animal ka hum ins- animal ki jo need hoti hai wo hum poori kar rahe hain. Dog ki need kya hoti hai? Hum dog, hum dog ko kaise, kis tareeke se dekhte hain?
For example, agar hum ek chidiya ko dekhenge, ek chidiya, chidiya kya animal hai? Theek hai, usko bhi safety chahiye, usko bhi shelter chahiye, usko bhi khaana chahiye. Lekin antar kya hai? Ab antar kya aa gaya? Dog ko walk chahiye, chidiya ko udna chahiye, machhli ko tairna chahiye.
Hai na? So is tareeqe se hum dekhte hain. Oh! Ab yeh species par pahunch chuka hai. Uske baad kya aata hai? Breed. Rott-Rottweilers hai, uh, Border Collies hai. Inko, isko Border Collies hai. Ek minute hold karein. Aaya hai toh woh ghoomta hai toh dogs abhi bark kar rahe hain us par. Hai na?
So woh khula hi ghoomta hai baahar ke corridor mein ghoomta rehta hai. And so, so is tareeqe se hum dog ko dekhte hain. Animal ki tarah dekhte hain, uske baad hum usko species ki tarah dekhte hain, uske baad hum usko breed ki tarah dekhte hain.
For example, agar aapke paas ek hunting dog hai, hunting instincts hai, koi hunting breed hai. Suppose kar lo Border Collies hai aapke paas, Jack Russells hai, koi Terrier hai aapke paas, Pitbull Terrier hai koi aapke paas. Unka kya instinct, unka breed ka instincts kya hunting hai.
Kisi-kisi breed ka instincts running hota hai. Kisi-kisi breed ka instinct chasing hota hai. Agar hum usko poora nahi karte toh for example, jaise German Shepherds hote hain. Woh ek breed hai. German Shepherd mein herding ka ek instincts hota hai. Agar hum usko poora nahi kar rahe hote toh woh kaise express hota hai?
Ankles par nip karke. German Shepherds ankles par nip karna start kar dete hain aur yeh bahut saare cases aate hain ki mera German Shepherd humare ankles par jab hum nikalte hain toh aise aakar nip karta hai, kaatta nahi hai, nip karta hai. Woh German Shepherd kya kar raha hai?
Apni herding ki instincts ko release kar raha hai. Okay, so is tareeqe se hum animal ko poora karte hain, safety provide karte hain. Uske baad hum uski species ko poora karte hain. Jaise walk par jaana hai, hai na, usko play karna hai, usko socialize hona hai.
That is all species level. Uske baad kya aata hai? Breed level jo hai work level. Yaani us dog ka work kya hai? So German Shepherd ka work kya tha? Herding karna. Toh humare paas cases kya aate hain? Nipping ke, whining ke, biting ke. Woh kyon ho rahe hain?
Uski hunting ki instinct, uski herding ki instincts poori nahi ho rahi hai. So as a behaviorist humko yeh figure out karna hota hai ki kaun si need, animal ki need poori nahi ho rahi hai, species ki need poori nahi ho rahi hai, breed ki need poori nahi ho rahi hai ya phir personality ki need poori nahi ho rahi hai.
So breed ki need tumhe samajh mein aaya. Ab personality ki kya need hoti hai? Personality ki need hoti hai, kisi dog ko zyada pyaar chahiye hota hai, kisi dog ko zyada, uh, closeness chahiye hoti hai, kisi dog ko thodi doori chahiye hoti hai. Har ek dog, same breed ke dog aise different tareeqe se behave karte hain.
Woh hoti hai unki individual personality. Kisi dog ko ghus ke rehna pasand, pasand lagta hai.
Kisi dog ko table ke andar rehna pasand hota hai. Kisi dog ko oopar heighted pe pasand hota hai. Woh wahan par safe feel karta hai. So yeh ho gayi unki personalities. So hum dog ko is layer se dekhte hain. Toh yeh, is, isko hum bolte hain behaviorist lens yaani behaviorist ka nazariya.
Ki hum kis tareeqe se dog ko analyze karte hain, kis dog, kis tareeqe se dog ko observe karte hain. So hume animal se start hona hota hai. Okay? Now, dog as a species ka matlab kya hai? So dog as a species ka matlab kya, matlab kya hota hai? Dog ki apni khud ki ek needs hoti hain. Aur woh needs kaisi ho sakti hain?
For example, agar hum ek species pakdein, uh, machhli pakad li humne. Ek machhli ek species hai. Toh uski kya need hogi? Uski tairna need hogi ki woh bina taire kaise jee sakti hai.
Agar humne usko chhote usmein band kar diya toh aapko machhli ke andar kya dekhne ko milega? Frustration dekhne ko milega. Uske andar jhanjhalaahatpan dekhne ko milega. Agar humne usko band kar diya toh. Woh, woh tair nahi paayi toh. Hai na? Usi tareeqe se agar humne ek chidiya ko band kar diya.
Okay, chidiya ko band kar diya toh kya hum, humein uske andar frustration dekhne ko milegi? Humein uske andar, woh kitna bhi walk kar rahi ho chidiya, lekin uske andar frustration dekhne ko milegi kyonki woh ud nahi paa rahi hai.
So usi tareeqe se dog ki apni needs hoti hai aur dog ki apni needs, sabse pehli need kya hoti hai? Travel karna. Yeh dog ki need hoti hai. Dogs walk karte hain. They walk lagataar. Kabhi idhar se, kabhi udhar jaana, kabhi idhar ja, jaise aap cow ki need kya hoti hai? Walk karte hue khaana khaana.
Agar cow ki need poori nahi hoti na, woh raat bhar pareshaan rahegi.
Hum usko khaana bhi de rahe hain na, lekin agar woh chalkar khaana nahi khaa rahi hai, graze nahi kar rahi hai toh usko dikkat hogi. Woh inki species ki needs hai. Usi tareeqe se dog ki apni species ki need hoti hai aur woh hai walking.
Agar aap usko walk nahi de rahe ho, kitna bhi khel rahe ho, kuch bhi kar rahe ho toh uske andar aapko woh, uh, sense of, uh, calmness nahi milegi uske andar. Isliye walk sabse important hum cheez bolte hain.
Kyonki walk unki jaise machhliyon ki tairna hoti hai, chidiyon ki udna hoti hai aur waise hi dogs ki walk karna hoti hai. So walk yeh species ki need hai. Socializing species ki need hai. Bahut se dogs alag tareeqe se socialize hote hain lekin socialize hote hain.
Socializing ka for example yeh nahi hota ki hum unke oopar chadh jaayein ya hum unke oopar baat kar lein ya phir hum unke se lagataar baat karein. Uska socialize ka matlab nahi hota. Socialize ka matlab yeh hota hai ki humare presence mein ya phir kisi aur ke presence mein dog kis tareeqe se behave kar raha hai.
Woh shaant hai ki nahi hai. Toh agar humare oopar chadhne se woh shaant nahi ho raha hai toh yaani ki hum socialize theek se nahi kar rahe hain. Humare peeche rehne se woh shaant nahi ho raha hai aur woh ho raha hai toh hum socialize theek se nahi kar rahe hain.
Bahut se dogs ko pyaar chahiye hota hai pehle shaant hone ke liye. Okay? Aur bahut se dogs ko doori chahiye hoti hai pehle shaant hone ke liye. So yeh again dekhiye socialize hote hain lekin unki personality unke saath combine hone lag jaati hai. Kisi-kisi dog ko socialize pasand hai lekin slowly pasand hai.
Kisi-kisi dog ko socialize pasand hai lekin ekdam excitement mein pasand hai. Toh har ek dog ka yeh different hota hai lekin socializing unki ek need hai. Play unki need hai. Agar dog ki play aur yeh play sirf dog ki need nahi species ki nahi hoti.
Lagbhag saare species mein play ek need hai including humans. Okay? So bahut se dogs akele rehte hain aur unke saath koi human play nahi karta. That is ek behaviorist usko dekhta hai aur usko batata hai ki iske saath play session zaroori hai. Woh khud hi khelta rehta hai cheezon se. Okay?
Khud hi khelta rehta hai cheezon se. Lekin har ek species mein play khud ke saath nahi play kisi ke saath hota hai. Matlab it's like you play with you bond with someone toh us tareeqe se woh dogs ki need hoti hai. So hum, hum sirf yahi nahi dekhte ki usmein kya issues hain, kya cheezein aa rahi hai.
Hum yeh dekhte hain ki kya-kya needs poori nahi ho rahi hai. Theek hai. Behaviorist ka lens kya dekhta hai? Kya issue nahi, kya-kya cheezein poori nahi ho rahi hai aur kaun se layer par poori nahi ho rahi hai.
For example, ek dog ko agar bandhe rakhoge aur wo chillayega aur tumhare paas case aayega ki hamara dog chillata bahut hai toh uski animal ki need poori nahi ho rahi hai. Wo hai freedom. Toh phir hum kya uski barking par work nahi kar sakte.
Okay, tab humein unko batana hota hai ki aap yahan se like freedom se start kijiye. Okay, so yeh behaviorist ka lens hota hai. Hum dog ko har ek layer par dekhte hain aur species ke layer par jab wo species ke layer par aata hai walk unki first need hai.
So maximum jo aapke behavioral issues hum handle karte hain walk se bahut tune down ho jaate hain aur mere experience mein 90% se upar cases walk se solve ho jaate hain. So it's a huge number.
So humein kya samajh mein aata hai ki jo dogs mein cases aa rahe hain, behavioral issues aa rahe hain that is because unki primary need poori nahi ho rahi hai.
Not just because ki wo broken hai. Not just because ki human ne kuch galtiyan kari hai. Nahi, just uski ek need poori nahi ho rahi hai because jo hamare paas statistic hai, jitna humne experience kiya, jitna humne cases liye hain. Walk improve hote hi poori dynamics improve ho jaati hai.
So dog ki sabse badi need hoti hai aur wo hai walk. And walk kaise-kaise deni hoti hai. Yeh ek different matter hai jo main aapse poochunga bhi sahi aapke exam mein ki kaise deni hoti hai. Jo baaki batch 2 ke hain wo dheere-dheere learn karenge is cheez ko.
Okay, bas lekin aapke liye overview yeh hai dog as a species ka walk is the most important thing. Okay, do cheez maine abhi cover kar li hai behaviorist lens ki most important cheez kya thi? Chaar layers behaviorist lens ki. Okay, dog as a species ki main, main cheez kya hai?
Main wo kya unki need aur wo kya hai? Walk. Theek hai, so walk. So teesri cheez par aate hain ki dog experience kaise karta hai apni reality ko. For example, for jaise aapko pata hai like different bats ki like sonar hota hai unke paas. Unko aise dikhta nahi jaise hume, hume dikhta hai.
Like they have a sonar kind of thing. Wo, wo sound ki vibration phenkte hain. Sound ki vibration takraakar waapas unke paas pahunchti hai aur unko samajh mein aata hai ki saamne obstacle hai. Wo dekh nahi sakte. Isn't it amazing? Like wo sonar se samajhte hain. Like wo sound ke usse samajhte hain.
Toh ye unke is tareeqe se wo reality dekhte hain. Bees ke itni saari lenses hoti hain ki unko saare degree mein dikh raha hota hai. 360 degree mein usko uska vision hota hai. So isko kitna alag hai humans se.
Usi tareeqe se dogs ka bhi alag hai reality ko dekhne ka. So hum kai baar hum sabse badi galti kya, kya kar rahe hote hain ki jis tareeqe se humein reality dikh rahi hai, usi tareeqe se hamare dog ko bhi reality dikh rahi hai. Aur yeh toh galti phir bhi chalti hai.
Hum aisa sochte hain ki baaki sabko bhi same reality dikh rahi hai. So every individual has their own reality aur every species has a completely different reality. So hum same species mein hi hamari different realities hoti hai. Matlab aap like ek male human, ek female human is duniya ko different nazar se dekhta hai.
Different colors dikhte hain. Nazar toh chhod hi do. Colors ke shade hi different dikhte hain. Aur dog ek different species hai. So dog ki reality chaalu hoti hai uski nose se, touch aur nose se. Sabse pehle uska touch sabse prominent rehta hai. Touch sabse zyada prominent, prominent rehta hai.
So hamara touch bahut zyada matter karta hai. Jab wo paida hote hain, jab wo paida hote hain toh hum hamesha bolte hain ki nose open hoti hai. Touch bhi ek sense hai. Touch bhi ek sense. Har, har koi bolta hai nose open hoti hai. Yes, nose bhi ek sense hai aur touch bhi ek sense hai.
Lekin sabse pehle touch chaalu hota hai unka. Unka touch chaalu. Hum touch ko is tareeqe se consider nahi kar rahe the. Pehle hum hamesha nose ko consider kar rahe the. So touch, unka jo touch hota hai wo sabse pehle, sabse pehle trigger hota hai. Wo sabse pehle touch se chaalu hote hain.
Din dheere-dheere unka nose ka start hota hai. Lekin uske baad bhi nose ek important part leti hai. Kyunki touch toh jab touch ho raha hai tab kaam aata hai. Touch toh jab touch hota hai tab kaam aata hai. Agar dog matlab door hai apni maa se toh wo maa ko find touch se thodi karega.
Toh uska touch strong part nahi hota. Uska sabse strong part uski nose hoti hai.
Kyunki uski nose par depend karta hai uska survival. Agar uski nose, uski nose agar strong nahi hogi toh wo survive kar payega kya? Wo apni maa ko dhoondh payega kya? Usko pata hi nahi chalega uski maa kidhar hai. Kyunki uske kaan toh band rehte hain. Agar maa oon-oon karegi toh usko sunai dega kya? Nahi.
Uski aankhein toh band rehti hai toh usko dikhai dega kya? Nahi. Uske paas kya bacha? Touch aur nose. Aur touch kab? Jab wo connect hoga. Aur jab connect nahi hai toh kya kaam aayega? Nose. So dog apni zindagi shuruwaat se nose se figure out karna start kar de. Nose se aur ye sabse badi mistake karte hain humans.
Kyunki jab hum dog ko ghar par lekar aate hain, hum sound se start karte hain. Sound ka matlab kya hai? Dog ke perspective mein ears. Samajh mein aaya? Agar hum sound use karte hain toh hum kis tareeqe se uski reality mein aa rahe hain?
Ears ke through aa rahe hain. Lekin dog apni reality ko dekhna kahan se chaalu karta hai? Nose se. Uske baad wo kahan se dekhna chaalu karta hai? Eyes se. Nose sabse pehle khulti hai. 15 din ke baad aankhein khulti hain aur 21 din ke baad kaan khulte hain. So kaan 21 days ke baad khulte hain.
Wo sabse least hota hai unki survival ke liye. Kyon sabse least hota hai? Wo kaan sabse aakhir mein kyon khulte hain? Shuruwaat mein unke heart weak hote hain. Agar tez aawaaz aayi, wo darenge aur heart burst ho jayega unka. Ki ye kya hua? Unko dikhega nahi. So wo accumulate hote hain. smell se lete hain.
Har cheez lete hain aur dheere-dheere kaan tak pahunchte hain. Okay? So nose unka sabse primary sense hai. Wo nose, ab nose ka matlab kya? Nose ka matlab kya hua? Humein jo smell aa rahi hai, dog ko usse kai zyada guna, kya number hai?
10 hazaar guna number hai. Kisi ko number ya-ya 10 thousand power zyada hai hamari nose se, dogs ke paas. 10 thousand. 10 thousand nahi toh 1 lakh hai. It's a huge number. 10 thousand to- 1 million receptors hote hain. Yeah, this is, see, haan so that's a, nahi matlab humse itna guna zyada hai.
human se compare karein toh. Kuch 10 hazaar se 1 lakh guna zyada power hoti hai kyunki different-different breeds mein different power hoti hai. Bahut se breeds mein bahut taakatwar nose bhi hai, jo hounds hain. Haan so-so unki nose unki reality banaati hai. Unki nose unki reality banaati hai.
So ye humein kahan madad karta hai? Dog se baat karne se pehle uski nose ko istemaal hone do. So jitne bhi fear ke cases dikhenge aapko, wahan par ek issue aapko same milega aur wo issue ye milega jo uske humans hain wo dog se bahut zyada baat karte hain.
Bahut zyada baat karte hain. So dog jab apni nose istemaal karta hai, wo shaant ho, ye kahan kaam aata hai? Jab dog apni nose istemaal karta hai, wo shaanti ki taraf badhta hai. Jab dog apni aankhein aur kaan istemaal karta hai, wo alertness aur nervousness ki taraf badhta hai.
Toh as a behaviorist humein kya karna hota hai? Humein apni approach silence mein rakhni hoti hai taaki dog apni nose sabse zyada istemaal kar sake. Jab kabhi dog panic hota hai toh hum usko treat nahi dikhaate. Hum usko smell zaroor sungha sakte hain. Ye kahan kaam aata hai? Taaki wo apni nose istemaal kare.
So dog apni nose istemaal karta hai then wo in cheezon ko kam karna start karta hai. So dog ki reality uski nose se banti hai, uske senses se banti hai. Lekin nose se jo reality banti hai, wo shaanti ki taraf jaati hai.
Aankhein aur kaan se jo reality banti hai, wo panic aur alertness ki taraf jaati hai. So ye humein apne cases mein implement karna hota hai aur wo kaise hum implement karte hain?
Agar kisi dog mein anxiety zyada dikhti hai ya phir aapko nervousness zyada dikhti hai toh hum unke human se baat karne ke liye kam bolte hain. Aur every process mein dog ki nose istemaal hone, zyada bolte hain ki aap log ki nose zyada istemaal kar sako. Okay? So is tareeqe se wo dog ki reality create hoti hai.
So again, is cheez mein, is-is topic mein kya important cheez hai? Jab dog apni aankhein aur ears istemaal karta hai toh wo more alert aur more nervous hota hai. Wo jitni zyada apni nose istemaal karta hai, wo utna hi balance ki taraf jaata hai. Okay? Toh is topic mein ye important, ye important cheez thi.
So uske baad aata hai association based thinking. For example, ab dekho, wo apne senses se data le raha hai. Lekin us data ka meaning kya hai? Okay, so us data ka meaning kya hai, usko association based thinking bolte hain. Data se kuch jab meaning attached hota hai, wo uski ek association create karta hai. Data kaise?
Usne smell kiya aapko. Okay, aapko smell kiya. Aapki ek particular tareeqe ki smell hai jo kisi ki bhi nahi ho sakti. Sab maante hain is baat ko. Hum sab ki ek unique smell hai. Dog ke perspective se toh zabardast unique smell hai. Bhale hi hum kitna cologne ya kitna bhi kuch bhi laga lein.
Dog ke perspective se hamari bahut, hamare andar ki chemistry ekdam unique hai. Dog us sab cheezon ko note karta hai. Okay? Jab wo in cheezon ko note kar raha hai, wo ye sochega ki iska matlab kya?
For example, jab aisi khushboo ya aisi smell aur as-as-aisa-aisi sight ya phir aisa shareer ya aisa face hamari taraf aa raha hai toh uska matlab kya hai? Toh jab aap darwaaze, darwaaza kholte ho, andar aate ho aur wo aapko smell karta hai aur aapko dekhta hai toh uske dimaag mein kya aata hai? Iska matlab kya hai?
Excitement. Iska matlab kya hai? Calmness. Toh humne kai baar suna hai na, main agar paanch saal ke baad bhi apne dog se mile-mila toh bhi usne waise hi behave kiya jaise wo waise behave karta tha.
Ya phir main ek minute ke baad bhi mila toh bhi wo aise behave karta hai jaise main paanch saal ke baad mil raha hoon, itna khush. Ye kai baar, ye kai baar humne suna hai na. That is, usko ye nahi samajh mein aata ki aap kitne time baad mile ho. Wo time consider nahi karta. Wo kya consider karta hai?
Ye shareer, ye jo mujhe dikh raha hai aur jisko main smell kar sakta hoon aur jisko main sun sakta hoon, uska matlab kya hai?
Us data ka matlab kya hai? Toh us data ka matlab wo kuch bhi ho sakta hai. For example, cylinder ki gaadi ki aawaaz aayi, uska matlab kya hai? Agar suppose kar lo koi pataakhe ki aawaaz aayi toh uska matlab kya hai? Koi saamne se bike chalti aa rahi hai, uska matlab kya hai?
Toh kisi ke liye matlab side ho ja ho sakta hai, kisi ke liye, kisi ka matlab ho sakta hai chase kar. Unke dimaag mein unhone kya matlab diya hua hai us cheez ka. Isko bolte hain association based thinking. Okay, association based thinking aur isi tareeqe se dog behave karte hain.
Association based thinking ban bhi sakti hai aur mid bhi sakti hai. Ye out of habit hoti hai. So association based thinking kitna deeply dog build karta hai, wo depend karta hai wo kitna tagde tareeqe se emotions ko express kar raha hai us samay par.
Agar emotion ka expression bahut zyada hai toh association based thinking deep hai. For example, jaise aapne dog ko aap sit sikha rahe ho. Okay, aapne treat li aur aapne usko sit sikhaana bhi chaalu kiya. Toh shuruat mein dikkat aati hai sit sikhaane mein.
Sit loge, wo thoda samjhega, thoda baithega, phir baith jaayega. Phir thode time ke baad kya hoga? Thoda samjhega, thoda jaldi baithega. Phir teesri baar kya hoga? Aap zara sa haath aise karoge aur wo baith jaayega. Theek hai, baith jaayega. So ismein kya hua?
Association based thinking mein time laga teen din, chaar din, paanch din. Theek hai, ab wo kisi cheez ke paas ja raha hai, koi garam cheez hai. Usko pata nahi hai wo garam cheez hai. Ek pateela pada hua hai, ek garam cheez hai. Usne jaise hi wahan par us par naak lagaayi, usko garam jhatka laga.
Kuch garam jhatka laga. Uske baad ab jahan bhi wo pateela dekhega, uske andar kya aayega? Darr aayega. Uske andar, uske andar darr kyon aayega? Kyunki jo em-emotion tha, pehli baar jo emotion tha, wo bahut deep tha, wo bahut bada tha. Usi tareeqe se ek high rewarding bhi ho sakta hai.
For example, aap ek aisi high rewarding treat lekar aaye jo aap usko kabhi nahi dete the aur dog aapka food motivated hai aur aap ek liver ki treat, liver ki treat le aaye.
Uske baad agar aap liver ki treat lekar aaye jo usko bahut zyada pasand hai, aap uske baad jo bhi cheez karaoge clearly karaoge wo usko ek baari mein samajh mein aa jaayega. Kyon? Wahan par emotion tagda hai. So associative, associative based thinking depend karti hai emotions ke upar.
Agar emotion down hai toh aapko multiple revision lagte hain.
Yeh habit hai. Multiple revision lagte hain habit baithaane ke liye. Isliye gaadi se ek baar takkar lagti hai uski thinking baith jaati hai na ki bhai this means kharaab. Lekin sit mein aisa nahi ho raha na. Usmein ekdam baith gayi na kyunki usmein emotions high the.
So associative based thinking hi behavior create karti hai aur associative based thinking highly depend karti hai do cheez par, repetitions par and emotions par, emotion ki intensity par. So aapka main, main cheez sochne ki kya hai yahan par?
Associ-- main important matter kya hai is jagah, is topic ke andar associative based thinking mein do cheez, do cheez intensity of emotion and repetition. Agar aapko koi bhi associative based thinking, koi bhi thinking create karni hai, koi bhi thinking break karni hai aapko toh aapko do cheezon ka dhyaan rakhna hai.
Intensity of emotion of dog. Emotion ki dog ki intensity kya hai emotion ki aur repetitions lagataar ho rahe hain ya nahi ho rahe. So aap koi bhi behavior ko tune up kar sakte ho aur koi bhi behavior ko tune down kar sakte ho. Because of this strategy, associative based thinking.
Dog ka saara behavior yahan se nikalta hai, associative based thinking se. Okay? So associative based thinking kya hai? Data input what it means and is equal to reactivity ki iska jo matlab hai ab mujhe is matlab se kaise react karna hai. Gaadi aa rahi hai uska matlab challenge hai, main lunge karunga.
Doosra kutta aa raha hai, wo territorial hai, mere andar darr hai, main self-defense mein lunge karunga. That is all associative based thinking. Okay? So wo depend karta hai emotions ki intensity par aur repetition ke upar.
Okay? So aap kisi bhi dog ke andar associa-- kisi ke andar, kisi bhi dog ke andar koi bhi habit create kar sakte ho aur koi bhi habit break kar sakte ho. Usme bas do cheez lagti hai repetition aur emotion ki intensity. Okay? Wo as a behaviorist humein figure out karni hoti hai jo aapke exam mein main poochunga. Okay?
Now, hum baat karenge social structure and stability ke baare mein. Okay? So social structure aur stability ke baare mein kya hota hai ki dog ko apne aaspaas ke environment se fark padta hai. Uska matlab kya aaspaas ka environment, kya aaspaas ka mostly environment hota hai humans.
So human ki energy, human ke environment, human ka day to day life ka baat karne ka tareeka, doosron se behave karne ka tareeka, dog se baat karne ka tareeka ya phir uske aaspaas jo bhi alag log hain jo dog se behave karte hain un sab cheezon se dog par fark padta hai.
For example, ghar mein ek banda hai jo bahut discipline, rules and regulations pe rakhta hai. Wo thoda discipline ke ek high use mein hai aur ek aur banda hai jo bilkul hi lenient hai dog ke saath. Wo har cheez allow karta hai.
So dog is environment mein ek confusion waali state mein rehta hai aur yeh confusion waali state uske andar anxiety lekar aati hai. Okay, so as a behaviorist humein kai baar yeh bhi samajhna hota hai ki saare jo family mein log hain wo kis tareeke se dog ke saath behave kar rahe hain.
Agar dog ke andar aapko confusion aur anxiety dikhta hai toh. So dog ke aaspaas ka pack uski stability aur aaspaas ke environment ki stability dog ke behavior ko impact karti hai. So isme main cheez kya hai? Is topic ke andar dog ka environment dog ke behavior ko shape karta hai.
Dog ke behavior ko stable karta hai. So sirf dog ke upar work nahi karna hota humein, humein us environment ko bhi dekhna hota hai. Kyunki us environment ko bhi dekhna hota hai. Now, chhatha, chhatha topic hai breed purpose and instincts expression.
Yeah, so how does presence of another ani-- Yeh pichhle topic ka ek question yeh hai ki kai baar aap yeh bhi sochoge ki bhai sirf human hi dog ke behavior ko impact karte hain kya? Nahi, aisa nahi hai.
Koi bhi being, ek chidiya bhi agar aap ek lekar aa rahe ho lekin us chidiya ki intensity kam hai toh dog kam wo karega. Lekin agar us intensity wo hai ki din bhar wo chillati rehti hai, jaise koi parrot aa gaya. Wo din bhar hi kuch na kuch bol raha hai usko toh wo zyada impact karega dog ko.
Bhai intensity par depend karta hai. For example, aap ek naya dog le aaye lekin uski intensity wo low energy dog hai toh wo itna, itna impact nahi karega jitna ek high energy dog impact kar sakta hai uske environment mein.
So environment mein kaun si energy aa rahi hai wo matter karti hai. So ek aisa being aa raha hai jiski energy low hai wo kam impact karega. Ek aisa being aa raha hai jiski energy high hai wo sabse wo zyada, zyada impact karega.
So dog isme samajhne ki baat yeh hai ki dog ka jo, dog ka jo behavior hota hai wo uska environment shape karta hai. Okay? So dog ka environment samajhna zaroori hota hai agar hum kisi dog ke behavior par kaam kar rahe hain. Now baat karte hain breed purpose aur instincts ke expression ke upar.
Har ek dog par koi na koi breed chhupi hai, bhale wo ek indie kyun na ho. Agar hum indie bhi dekhein wo kis tareeke se kahin na kahin se aa rahe hain.
Indie paraaya dog hi samajh lo ya koi bhi dog samajh lo usme kisi na kisi kyunki jitne bhi dogs hain na unko breed kiya gaya tha work ke liye, kuch kaam ke liye not companionship ke liye.
Aaj ke time par companionship ke liye breed kiya jaata hai. Pehle ke time par lekin dogs aaye toh udhar se hi hai na. So kisi na kisi breed mein aapko jo unka work waala culture hai, work waali jo instincts hai wo sabse zyada dekhne ko milegi.
So humein jaise German Shepherds hain, koi hunting breeds hain, koi terrier breeds hain, koi, koi jo play karne waali breeds hain, jo running karne waali breeds hain, run karke chase karne waali breed hai, wo gharon mein jab aa jaati hain aur hum unki is tarah ki need poori nahi kar paate hain toh bahut tabaahi machaate hain wo.
Aur unke andar bahut zyada behavioral issues create hota hai aur jisse hum bolte hain ki is dog mein problem hai. Wo phir bolenge ki Pitbull aise hi hote hain. Wo phir bolenge bhai Saluki aise hi hote hain. Hounds aise hi hote hain. Beagle toh aise hi karte hain. Lhasa Apso toh aise hi.
Jitni bhi aap baatein sunoge na Lhasa Apso aise hi hote hain, wo aisa hi karte hain.
Are wo aisa isliye kar rahe hain. Aisa maine hum keh rahe hain jaise for example Beagle lagataar howl karta rehta hai gharon mein. Ab Beagle kis liye breed? Bhai tumne pehle game hota, hote the ek kuch suppose kar lo chidiya maari tumne. Ab Beagle bhaag rahe hain wahan par. Wo cheez ko dhoondh rahe hain.
Us cheez ko wo, wo usko, wo hunt usko milta hai. Wo apni poonchh unki jhande jaisi hoti hai aur wo howl karte hain aur bataate hain ki yahan par ye hai. Ye unka game hai. Ab hum inko ghar mein lekar aaye lekin hum unko ye game nahi de rahe. Par us instinct ka kya hoga? Us Beagle ki instinct ka kya hoga?
Wo kidhar niklegi? Use bolte hain breed expression. Breed instincts expression. So breed ke instincts agar express nahi honge wo behavioral issues mein convert honge. So behavioral issue ya jo Beagle hai wo sab wo bahut har kisi ke aane par howl karega.
Gate khula koi guest aaya aur wo howl karega. Koi gate se baahar jaayega wo howl karega. Usko koi khilona dikh jaayega wo howl karega. So aise dogs ko nature mein outing lagti hai. Aise dogs ko nature mein running lagti hai aur us dog ke saath running lagta hai. Kyun? Beagle isi tareeke se shikaar par jaaya karte the.
Toh jab hum unko nature mein lekar jaate hain aur is tareeke se hum unke saath bhaagte hain, run karte hain tab unki breed ka expression, wo wahan par howl karenge jagah-jagah par jaakar. Tab jaake unke breed ka jo instinct hai wo express ho paata hai aur tab jaake ye behavioral issues mein convert nahi hota.
So iska sabse main important part kya hai? Breed purpose aur instinct. Har ek dog mein humein breed dekhni padti hai. For example, agar hum kisi Indy ka case lete hain toh humein uske andar breed dhoondhni padti hai ki iske andar kaun si breed ho sakti hai.
Bahut se ke andar humein kisi ke andar yahan par itna common nahi hai lekin phir bhi humein Indies ke andar Border Collies ke genes dikh jaate hain. Border Collies ke wo dikh jaate hain aur bahut se mein humein German Shepherds ke wo dikh jaate hain. Kisi mein humein Beagle ke wo dikh jaate hain.
Toh is tareeke se mix of breeds rehta hai uske andar. Toh Indies bahut mushkil hota hai cases, breed ke cases ko handle karna. Jo breed waale issues aa rahe hain, jo breed ke expression waale issues aa rahe hain, wo mushkil hota hai usko figure out karna un sab cheezon ko.
Wo Indies mein kyunki German Shepherd ko aap dekh sakte ho, German Shepherd hai. Iske herding ke instincts baahar aa rahe hain. Indies mein aap nahi de sakte. Toh unki, unki instincts ko dekhkar, unki behavior ko dekhkar phir humein reverse engineer karna padta hai iske iske andar kaun sa hoga.
Phir humein ideas milte hain ki iske andar ye, ye cheezein hoti hain. Ab iski shakl kisse match ho rahi hai? Iski harkatein kisse match ho rahi hain?
Toh us ba, uske baad humein samajh mein aata hai ki iske andar ye multiple breeds ho sakti hain aur un multiple breeds ki ab kya-kya needs hoti hai then hum wo apply karte hain uske upar. Then wo Indy phir theek hota hai.
Toh Indy ke agar shuruat ke jo issues aa rahe hain animal aur species ke jo issues aa rahe hain that is wo easily cover ho jaate hain. Aapko walk dena hai, aapko usko play dena hai. Lekin jo breed related issues aate hain usmein Indies sabse mushkil karte hain.
Okay, usmein bhi unko reverse engineer karna padta hai ki iske andar kaun si breed ho rahi hai. So breed ka ek purpose hota hai. Agar hum wo poora nahi karte hain toh dog ke andar behavior, aap kitne bhi unko walks de lo, kitna bhi wo de lo wo nahi maanenge. Warna unka, unka issues nahi jaayega.
So iska sabse main ye hai ki humein breed figure out karni hoti hai. Uska expression figure out karna hota hai aur dog ko way dena hota hai ki wo us cheez ko let out kar sake aur us cheez ko express kar sake uske instincts ko.
Okay? Now uske baad bahut important cheez aati hai aur isi jagah par sab log rehte hain. Most human is jagah par rehte hain. Usko bolte hain individual personality. Jo dog ki individual personality hoti hai log usi par rehte hain ki yeh dog aisa hi hai. Haan, mera Buddy toh aisa hi hai. Mera Bruno toh aisa hi hai.
Wo toh usko toh doosre dogs bilkul bhi pasand nahi hai. Wo toh aisa karega hi sahi. Usko toh khaane ke baad ye cheez chahiye hi hoti hai. Jab hum khaana khaate hain wo toh bark karta hi hai aur wo karega hi sahi.
So these all are inki personalities aur yahin par, ye sabse chhota part hota hai aur jisko sabse zyaada weightage diya hua hota hai humans ne. Matlab jinko dog psychology ki knowledge nahi hai wo personality ko sabse zyaada weightage dete hain.
Lekin personality least hai kyunki personality environment shape karta hai. Okay? Maximum jo personality hoti hai wo dog ki environment shape karta hai. So dog shuruat mein ye ho sakta hai ki usko thodi doori pasand hai. Wo thodi usko ye pasand hai.
Lekin jitni bhi uski habits create hoti hai ki bhai mujhe khaana khaane ke baad ye chahiye, mujhe iske baad ye chahiye. Jab bhi log aate hain mujhe us par jump karna hai. Mere ko ye sofa ka space pasand hai. Mujhe ye car ke aage waali seat hi pasand hai. These all are personality jo unke environment ne shape kari hai.
Ye dog nahi hai. Okay, ye humko samajhna, ye humko samajhna hota hai ki ye dog ki personality it's like ye environment ne shape hokar aayi hai. For example, khaane ke baad usko Marigold biscuit lagta hai.
Ab ye kya, ye, wo, ye, ye, ye kya, ye hai environment se shape hui hui personality ki agar usko, usko hum biscuit nahi dete toh wo bahut chillaata hai. Ye kya hai? Environment se shape hui personality. Dog ko jab sona hota hai aur hum uske paas jaate hain toh growl, growl karta hai.
Ye, ye environment shape waali personality nahi hai. Ye unka nature hai. Okay, ye unka nature hai. Dog, dog humare paas nahi aata. Wo humse thoda doori banakar rakhta hai. Ye environment shape personality nahi hai. Ye uska nature hai. Wo doori banakar, doori banakar rakhta hai. Dog ko mere paas ghusna bahut pasand hai.
Wo baar-baar aakar aise ghusta hai. Ye, ye, ye koi par wo nahi hai like environment shape personality nahi hai. Ye uska nature hai. Kisi dog ko closeness chahiye hoti hai, kisi dog ko. Lekin Marigold biscuit usko khaane ke baad chahiye hota hai. Usko car ke aage hi baithna hai.
Ye these all are personality shape, shaped by the environment.
Toh ye antar humko samajhna hota hai. Okay, so individual personality and emotional it's like personality samajh mein aayi lekin uske saath-saath ek emotional baseline bhi hai. Jo humein samajhna hota hai. Emotional baseline ka kya matlab hota hai? For example, tolerance level ki tarah dekh sakte ho is cheez ko aap.
Tolerance level ki tarah se samajh sakte ho emotional baseline ko. Jaise suppose kar lo aapne kai baar dekha hoga ki yaar koi kisi se sawaal poochhta hai toh koi frustrate ho jaata hai. Lekin wahi banda kisi aur se sawaal poochhta hai toh wo frustrate nahi hota.
Toh jo frustrate ho raha hai uski emotional baseline kam hai. Wo jaldi frustrate ho jaata hai cheezon ko lekar. Aur wahin par jo calmly de pa raha hai uski emotional baseline high hai. Wo, wo frustrate nahi hota. Wo, wo easily handle kar leta hai. Usi tareeke se dogs ke andar bhi same cheez hoti hai.
Same cheez hoti hai. Agar kis-- agar ek dog ka emotional baseline high nahi hai toh wo chhoti-chhoti baaton par chidh jaayega. Chhoti-chhoti baaton par chidh jaayega. Toh humein kya karna hota hai? Usko shaant rakhna hota hai. Usko exercise zyaada deni hoti hai taaki wo thaka rahe toh zyaada chidhe na.
Aur usi tareeke se ek high us par rahega toh log kya bolenge usko? Are isko toh hum kuch bhi kar lein, kuch bhi nahi bolta. Are uska tolerance level high hai kyunki. Isliye kuch nahi bolta. Toh bahut se dogs chhoti si cheez mein trigger ho jaate hain ki bhai ye kya hai yaar? Mere ko nahi chalta ye sab cheezein.
Aur bahut se dogs aise hote hain ki yaar kar lo kuch bhi sab chalta hai apan ko. Toh usi t-- jis tareeke se humans hote hain, us tareeke se dogs ke andar bhi emotional baseline hoti hai. Bahut se dogs a-jab tum unki taraf badh rahe honge ya agar, dog to dog socho, dog to dog socho, not human to dog.
So doosra dog ek dog ki taraf badh raha hoga, wo dog usko kuch nahi karega. Okay? Lekin wahi dog leta hua hoga aur doosra dog uski taraf badh raha hoga toh wo us par growl karega. Wo kyun gra-wo kyun growl, uski emotional baseline toh yahan par imp-matter karti hi karti hai.
Saath mein jo move ho raha hai uski taraf, uski emotional baseline bhi matter karti hai. Agar jo move ho raha hai uski taraf wo ek high intense hai aur usko wo intensity nahi chalti toh wo growl karega.
Agar ek aur dog uski taraf aa raha hai lekin wo, wo itna intense nahi hai, uske level ka hai toh wo growl nahi karega. Toh yahan par humein kya samajh mein aata hai ki dog fix nahi hai ki meri taraf badho hi mat. Tumhari intensity bhi matter karti hai. Aur kaise matter karti hai? Emotional baseline se.
Har ek dog ka emotional baseline hota hai aur wo apne emotional baseline se bhi dekhta hai aur saamne waale ke emotional baseline se bhi dekhta hai.
Toh kitna hai, kitna, kitna woh allow karega. So yahan par main cheez kya nikalti hai? Har ek dog ki individual personality hai aur har ek dog ka individual emotional baseline hai jo unique hai. Okay? Jo unique, u-unique hai. Toh yeh cheez samajh ke chalni hai aapko.
Now, a-iske baad aata hai communication through body energy and signals. Most humans sabse badi mistake kya karte hain dog ke saath baat karne ke liye? Baat karte hain. Words ka istemaal, words ka istemaal karte hain. Aur woh completely normal hai but from human perspective.
Kyunki hum ek doosre se kaise, kaise, kaise communicate karte hain? Shabdon ki tarah. Hai na? Yeh hamara tareeka hai. Yeh humans ka tareeka hai. Lekin kya yeh dog ka tareeka hai? Nahin, dog ek doosre se shabd use nahin karte.
Dog ek doosre se body language use karte hain. Woh ek doosre ko eye contact dete hain. Ek doosre ke saamne aa jaate hain. Halki si growl dete hain door karne ke liye. Lekin shabd unke us, shabd matlab barking bhi samajh lo. Growling bhi samajh lo. Chalo shabdon ko apan ismein convert kar lete hain.
Kuch sound mein convert kar lete hain. Barking bhi samajh lo, growling bhi samajh lo. Lekin woh kitna kam percentage hota hai unki communication ka.
Agar aapke paas ek se zyada dogs hai toh ya ek se zyada animal hai toh aapne dekha hoga ki woh just ek doosre ko dekhte hain, apni body ko saamne lekar jaate hain aur ek doosre se behave karte hain. Agar unko koi cheez uthani bhi hoti hai na ek doosre ke saamne se, woh bark aur growl nahin karte.
Woh apni body language se aise jaate hain aur phir cheezon ko uthate hain aur phir wahan se lekar jaate hain. So as a dog behaviorist, yeh hamara kaam hota hai seekhna ki kaise hum dog ke saath bina baaton se apni body aur energy se behave kar sakein.
Kyunki dog behaviorist is not, dog behaviorist yeh nahin karta ki dog ko human ke taur-tareeke nahin sikhata. Hum, dog behaviorist dogs ko human ke taur-tareeke nahin sikhata. Dog behaviorist humans ko dog ke taur-tareeke sikhata hai. Samajh mein aaya? Humein seekhne hote hain dog ke taur-tareeke as a behaviorist.
So as a behaviorist humein seekhna hota hai ki dog ek doosre se kaise communicate karte hain aur dog ek doosre se communicate karte hain through energy and body language, not through sound, not through voice. Theek hai? So is topic ka sabse important cheez kya hai?
Dog ka primary channel communication ka body and energy hai. Body language and energy. Hai na? Aur woh hum kaise incorporate kar sakte hain apni strategies mein ya dog ke saath behave karte waqt.
Aur woh zyada effective hota hai. Okay? Baaton se zyada. Aur aap sab logon ne ab jaake mehsoos bhi karne lage ho ki body language is more effective. Body language se communicate karna, energy se communicate karna much, much higher effective hai jab hum command se behave karte the, command se react karte the. Okay?
Ya hum sound se woh, woh cheez, woh cheez karte the. So iska sabse important, is topic ka sabse important thing kya hai? Dog ka primary communication through body language hai. Body language, not through sound, not through barking, not through growling.
Their body, their energy, their eye look ki woh aankhon mein kaise dekhte hain. Eyes sabse important cheez hai. Jab hum dog ki aankhon mein dekhte hain, hum kya oorja project kar rahe hain, us par bahut zyada matter karta hai.
Aur then uske baad hamari body ki kis tareeke se khadi hai aur kis tareeke se change ho rahi hai unko dekhkar.
Main aap logon ke saath more videos share karunga is body language ke upar. But abhi right now yeh theory ka part hai toh aapko yeh cheez samajhna zaroori hai ki dog ke saath agar humein behave karna hai toh humein priority kisko deni hai? Body language ko aur energy ko. Yeh do cheez ko. Okay? Now, aakhiri cheez.
See, poore modules ke overview completely ho chuka hai. It's not hard aur it's not ki woh bas aapko baar-baar is cheez ko samajhna zaroori hai. And kaafi ek framework hai dog ke us cheez ko samajhne ki, ki dog ke dimaag ko samajhne ke, dog ke behavior ko samajhne ke.
Lekin agar hum consistent repeat karenge is cheez ko toh aapka dimaag more habitual ho jaayega patterns ko read karne ke liye. Kyunki kai baar yeh hoga ki aap bhool jaao ki patterns mujhe kis pattern mein read karne hain.
That's the big-- like kaun se kis cheez mein mujhe pehle jaana hai, kidhar mujhe dekhna hai, kis taraf mujhe dekhna hai.
But it's not hard, but it takes repetition. It takes repetition. So now, main aapse baat karta hoon issues ke baare mein. So ek hi saath isko combination mein le raha hoon. Fear hai, anxiety hai. Maximum cases kaise aate hain?
Fear ke aate hain, anxiety ke aate hain, frustration ke aate hain, aggression ke aate hain, reactivity ke aate hain, territorial behavior aata hai, excessive barking aata hai, hyperactivity aata aata hai. All these things ko hum link kar sakte hain human ki ignorance se about dog.
Matlab is tareeke se like hum is tareeke se samajh sakte hain ki this is because jo yeh behavior ke issues aa rahe hain ghar ke andar that is only because ki human ignorant hai dog's ecology ko lekar.
Dog kis tareeke se behave karta hai, dog kis tareeke se uski needs poori karni chahiye aur kaise dog ke saath consistent rehna chahiye taaki dog ki ek habit create ho sake.
So most humans jo cheezein galtiyan karte hain woh consistency ko lekar hoti hai aur ek strategy ko lekar hoti hai. Unko koi idea nahin hota hai. Like dog ke saath shuruwaat mein koi i-aur aap bhi bahut se log is cheez mein agree karoge jab aapne dog liya hoga aapko koi idea nahin hoga.
Aur aaj ke time par agar aapko lagta hai ki aapko idea tha toh aaj ke time par aapko lagta hai woh galat idea tha. Hai na? Us idea se mera dog mein issues badh rahe the, jo mere ko idea tha. Toh woh, woh galat. So aap dekhiye, hum jaise hi log hain na, matlab hum, hamare paas yeh soch aayi toh kahan se soch aayi?
Hum jaise hi log hain na saare ke saare hum sab log hi. Toh sabke sab log aise hi soch rahe hote hain. Jo aap logon ki, jo hum logon ki soch hai ki dog aisa hota hai, dog aisa hota hai, dog ke saath aisa karna hai, dog ke saath aisa karna hai. Lekin ab, ab aap sabko pata hai ki aap sab galat the.
Aur woh sab issues create kar rahe hain. Maybe sab mein har ek cheez mein galat nahin the. Lekin phir bhi aap figure out kar sakte ho ki yaar bahut saari cheezon mein galat the aur woh hamare dog ke saath ek galat behavior set ho raha tha. Aur ho bhi raha tha. Ho bhi raha tha un sab cheezon ko lekar.
Toh aise hi poore log soch rahe hote hain. Aur yehi main kaaran hai dogs ke andar behavioral issue ka. Bhale hi woh fear ho, bhale hi woh anxiety ho. Dog sensitive zaroor paida hota hai. Sensitivity, insecurity ki taraf zaroor lead hoti hai.
Dog territorial zaroor paida hote hain aur territorial aggression ki taraf zaroor badhti hai. Lekin woh lead hoti hai. Woh uske saath paida nahin hote hain. Sensitivity, insecurity aur fear ki taraf lead hoti hai. Usko yaani ka lead hone ka matlab kya hai? Hum usko idhar redirect kar sakte hain.
Agar hum kahin par lead ho rahe hain toh hum usko redirect kar sakte hain na bhai kahin aur jaa, woh raasta sahi nahi hai, jahan tu jaa raha hai. Toh dog lead karta hai us taraf. Lead karne ka matlab kya hai? Woh iske saath paida nahi hua.
Agar woh iske saath paida nahi hua toh woh badhte, badhte, badhte, badhte is jagah par, is jagah par pahunch gaya jismein woh ek aggression par aa gaya, jismein woh frustration mein aa gaya, jismein woh hyperactivity mein aa gaya, jismein woh barking mein aa gaya. All these issues are linked back to what?
Mostly, main mostly bolun, main mostly, most, main mostly isliye bol raha hoon kyunki agar human ko knowledge bhi hogi aur human ke paas understanding bhi hogi lekin human ke paas kayi baar woh resource nahi ho sakta jo us dog ki need poori kar sake.
For example, suppose kar lo aap job karte ho, aap company mein jaate ho, aapka apna business hai.
Aapne ek dog adopt kar liya. Ab woh dog high aur hyper energy ka hai. High aur hyper energy ko din mein dhaai ghante ki exercise lagti hai aur ek job lagta hai. Ab woh insaan usko kaise provide karega? Samajh mein, agar hum usko knowledge bhi denge toh bhi woh provide nahi kar payega us cheez ko.
So bahut se, woh phir aap usko kitni bhi cheezein sikha lo lekin un dogs ke paas agar job nahi hota toh woh theek nahi ho paate. Unko phir job ki, job ki zaroorat hoti hai. Ab job ki zaroorat kya hota hai? Unko ek sniffing ka woh lagta hai ki bhai tumhe ek sniff, sniff karna hai, tumko is cheez ko figure out karna hai.
Agar tumhare paas ek, uh, us breed ka naam kya hai yaar? German Shepherd jaisi dikhti hai and bahut, uh- Belgian Malinois. Yeah, haan. Yeah, so this, ab, ab see, agar hum usko protection ka kaam nahi denge jiske liye woh bani hai, jiske liye woh breed hoti aayi hai, phir kya hoga?
Phir, phir usko kaise, ab jis human ke paas hai woh, uske paas resources hi nahi hai woh cheez dene ke liye. So hamare paas shuruat mein ek Belgian Malinois ka case aaya tha jisne mujhe bite bhi kiya tha, lekin woh ek insecure bandi thi. Woh insecure, woh, woh, woh ek insecure thi.
Uski jab humne walk increase kari toh kuch fark nahi pad raha tha. Lekin jab humne uski do ghante ki running increase kari, ek se dedh ghante ki running increase kari, tab jaake uspe fark padna start kiya. Toh saamne, saamne waale ke paas woh resources bhi hone chahiye us dog ke upar work karne ke liye.
So agar bahut zyada mismatch hai, mismatch samajhte ho kaise hota hai dog ka aur ismein? Dog ki energy high aur high par hai aur jo human uske saath hai woh low, medium hai. Ab woh human apne aap ko kitna badhayega taaki woh high aur hyper tak pahunch sake? Woh bahut mushkil hota hai high aur hyper tak pahunchana.
Wahan par humein kya dena hota hai unko? Tools dene hote hain. Kis tareeqe ke tool? Treadmill deni hoti hai. Ki bhai tumse nahi bhaag payega, scooty deni hoti hai. Scooter dene hote hain. Kyunki woh nahi bhaag sakta na do ghan, ek ghante tak. Lekin woh dog ko toh ek ghante ki running chahiye.
Toh humein ise figure out karna hota hai. Agar ab woh cheez nahi hoti hai toh dog ke andar behavioral issues aane lag jaate hain. Woh bolenge ki yaar main toh ek-ek ghante ki walk de raha hoon. Lekin woh dog high aur hyper hai. Usko ek ghante ki walk nahi chalegi.
Usko aur zyada chahiye lekin woh aur zyada provide nahi kar sakte. So unko knowledge thi ki dog ko yeh dena hai. Unko knowledge thi ki yeh karna hai. Lekin unke paas kitna karna hai us cheez ka woh gyaan nahi tha. Aur woh kaise karna hai us cheez ke baare mein pata nahi tha.
So dogs koi bhi issues ke saath paida nahi hote. Aapko puppies ke andar issues nahi milenge, lekin, aur free roaming dogs mein bhi aapko issues nahi milenge.
Woh ek doosre se jhagadte hain, woh hunt karte hain, lekin woh issues nahi hai. Woh unka nature hai. Woh kisi bhi human ki taraf, kisi bhi gaadi ki taraf kabhi bhi chase karte hue nahi dikhai de. They pretty, they live pretty peaceful life.
Unko koi matlab nahi hota, koi woh, kisi human ki taraf nahi bhaagte, kisi human ki taraf aggressive nahi hote. Lekin jo gharon mein rehna start karte hain dogs, hamari chaar deewari ke peeche rehna start karte hain, unke andar sabse zyada behavioral issues hote hain aur yehi sochne ki baat hai kyun? Okay?
Aur yeh jo poora hamara course hai, poori hamari community hai, uska maqsad bhi yehi hai ki taaki aap log in cheezon ko samjho aur is cheez ka jo gyaan hai aage lekar jaao, logon ko batao taaki unko samajh mein aaye ki dogs broken nahi hai. Broken hamari approach hai.
Toh hum apni approach ko change karenge aur wohi sabse badi baat hai jo log ghabraate hain apni approach ko change karne mein.
Humein ghabraana nahi chahiye. Lekin hamari approach jab change hogi tabhi yeh issues khatam honge. Aur as a behaviorist hi hamara kaam hota hai. Jo humans hai unki approach ko change karana. Overall kya ho raha hai? Maine aap logon ke saath kya kara? Aapki approach change kari na. Aur kya, aur kya kara?
Aapki jo approach thi aapke dog ko lekar wohi change kari. Change your approach toh dog ka behavior change ho raha hai. Lekin woh approach hai kya? Woh approach karna kya hai? Aur saath mein kyun karna hai? Aur main teri sunu kyun? All aur yeh sab, yeh sab cheezein aati hain.
Toh yeh sab cheezein face karenge aur in sab cheezon se upar niklenge. Lekin woh sab ke sab tab hoga jab aapke paas deep understanding hogi. So deep understanding ke liye calls poore attend kijiye.
Courses se go through hoiye aur jitne main reading ka material de raha hoon aur aap, main agar aap is group mein hai toh main aapko samajh ke chal raha hoon ki you all are serious.
Aap dog ko aur deeply padhna chahte ho. So jitne bhi material de raha hoon please usko read kijiye. Shuruat mein time lagta hai. Koi bhi nayi cheez seekhte ho na, shuruat mein time lagta hai. Shuruat mein aapko doubts aate hain ki yaar yeh sahi hai ki nahi hai jo main kar raha hoon. Ismein bahut time lag raha hai.
Main kabhi seekh paunga ya nahi seekh paunga. Woh sirf shuruat ka time hota hai. Ek baar jab foundation set ho jaati hai na, aapki growth bahut fast hogi. Aur yeh har ek nayi skill par hai. Koi bhi nayi skill par jaoge, shuruat mein aapko achha lagega.
Arre waah, yeh seekhenge, yeh seekhenge aur jaise hi woh skill seekhna chaalu karoge aur aapko lagega yaar main toh kitna, kitna like mere ko toh kuch samajh nahi aa raha. Main kitna dumb hoon ya phir kitna like kya bolte hain yaar anything hai na ki mujhe kuch samajh nahi aa raha aur yeh mere laayak hai bhi nahi.
Itna time lag raha hai, itna time dena pad raha hai aur meri growth nahi ho pa rahi hai.
Kab main dog ko samjhunga aur kab main dog ko samjhungi and then kab uske issues figure out honge? Shuruat mein time lagta hai har ek skill ke saath. Lekin jab aap usmein rehte ho tab aage jaati hai. Woh exponentially grow hoti hai aur yeh woh main apne saath experience kar raha hoon.
Toh jo meri knowledge thi pehle woh abhi different hoti ja rahi hai. Lekin jis rapidly woh badh rahi hai dog ko understanding ka woh different hai. Woh faster hai pehle se. Toh woh kaise? Because ek foundation set hai aur aap logon ki yahan par woh foundation maine bahut saalon mein set kari.
Lekin woh foundation main aap logon ko set karke de raha hoon. Bas aapko consistent hokar rehna hai uske upar. Aur jo main aapke saath share kar raha hoon usko read karna hai. That's it guys. Aaj yeh do, do module humne cover kiye aur dono module mein maine behaviorist lens ke baare mein bataya.
Sabka overview diya aapko, thoda-thoda diya hai. Behaviorist lens ke baare mein bataya aapko. Dogs as a species ke baare mein bataya.
Dogs kaise experience karte hain apne reality ko. Yes, Kashish group mein share hai. Main phir se link deta hoon unko reading materials ko. So dog kaise experience karte hain? Apni nose ki tarah experience karte hain. Association based thinking kya hoti hai? Wo aapko bataya.
Kaise meaning nikaalte hain aur kaise wo react karte hain. Social structure stability kya hota hai? Wahi bataya. Kaise environment shape karta hai unke behavior ko. Breed ka purpose kya hota hai aur wo kyon usko express karne dena zaroori hota hai.
Agar hum behavioral issues nahin chahte hain, jo deep behavioral issues hote hain aur Indies mein sabse mushkil ye wale issues hote hain solve karna. Okay? Kisi aur dog mein nahin, Indies mein sabse zyada mushkil hote hain jo breed related hai. Not overall, only breed, breed related issues bhi hote hain.
Like German Shepherd ka herding ka instinct jo ankles ko nip karta hai, wo breed related issue hai.
Usi tareeqe se Indies ke andar bhi hote hain. Wo humein figure out karne hote hain. Sab dog ki apni individual personality hai aur personality hai aur emotional baseline hai. Usi tareeqe se dog ek doosre se communicate karte hain not through words, through body language and energy.
And aakhir mein jitne bhi issues hain dogs ke andar genetically hata do toh sab kuch lead karte hain kahan par? Human ki understanding ki kami mein. Lack of understanding pe and then phir lack of resources kyonki uske baad wo resource hai ki nahin wo understanding ko implement karne ka. Okay?
So this is the two modules jiske baare mein hum sawaal main aapse course mein poochhoonga. And abhi chhote se QnA rakhte hain and 10-15 minutes ki, 10 minutes ke liye and then we will close it down.
Yes, Kashish.
Kashish
Aapki instinct aur iska jab padha rahe hain toh jab main module mein revision mein padh rahi thi toh aapne ek na mujhe abhi sorry wo term exactly use nahin aa raha. Toh wahan aapne likha tha ki instinct above or maybe species above instinct or maybe instinct above species mujhe yaad nahin aaya. Toh aapne wo bola tha.
Sunny
Instinct is above, above, above the species. Yeah.
Kashish
Toh, toh wo kya ki wo usko brain mein oopar rakhenge. Toh wo mujhe samajh nahin aaya tha. Can you maybe explain that?
Sunny
So jaise dogs ki for, for example jaise dog ki instincts hoti hain. For example ki agar koi, koi, koi bhaag raha hai. Hai na? Koi cheez bhaag, mujhe chase karna hai. That's it. Hai na? Koi bhaag raha hai, mujhe hunt karna hai. Agar wahan se rabbit nikal ke gaya toh mere ko hunt karna hai. That's the instincts unki.
So agar hum usko break karna, usko hum break karna chahte hain, wo sabse difficult hoti hai.
Instincts ko, instincts ko break karna. So instincts ko break karne ke liye humein kuch leverage chahiye hota hai. For, for example agar yahan par dog bhaagte hain, yahan dog bhaagte hain. Mere jo dogs hain yahan par, wo rabbit ke, rabbit ke oopar bhaagte hain.
Lekin yahan ke dogs pe kabhi bhi collar aur leash nahin rakha hai. Toh mere paas leverage kya hai? Mere taang jo tez bhaag sake, unke saamne aa sake. Then only I can stop them. Main peeche se call karke bulaakar unko stop nahin kar sakta. Okay?
So agar humein kisi dog ki instincts rokni hogi, we need some kind of leverage for them. For example ghar ke dogs mein kya hoti hai? Ek long leash ek leverage ho sakti hai. Hum usko leash se uski instincts ko rok sakte hain. Toh hum kaise, kaise isko overcome karte hain?
Hum baar-baar wo instincts ko trigger karte hain aur leash se rokte hain. Instinct ko trigger karte hain, leash se rokte hain.
Over a period time kya hota hai? Hum instinct se oopar ho jaate hain. Lekin usmein consistency lagti hai. Ab samajh mein instincts ka kya matlab hai Kashish? Toh instincts is like koi bhi herding chaalu ho gaya. German Shepherd mein herding chaalu ho gaya uski instincts ko dekhkar.
Ya phir kisi mating ka instinct hota hai. Tum mating instincts ko rok nahin paaoge. It's the most powerful, powerful than the prey matlab jo prey hota hai. Wo aap phir mating ka, ek mating ke time par hi dog ek doosre ko kill kar sakte hain. Bhai-bhai kill kar sakta hai. Pack-pack mein kill kar sakta hai.
Kill, it's not ki maarna-dhaadna, kill tak chala jaata hai maamla. So that's wo instincts ko hum handle nahin kar sakte. Wo instincts ko kaise handle kar sakte hain? Dog ko jail mein daalkar yaani chaardeewaari, apna ghar.
Tabhi wo handle ho sakta hai. Uske baad bhi wo chillaayega. Lekin agar wo baahar hai toh aap usko leash se bhi handle nahin kar paaoge. Leash se bhi handle nahin kar paaoge.
So instincts bahut powerful hote hain aur instincts jab powerful hote hain toh humein bachpan se hi dog ko habit daalni hoti hai us cheez ki ki hum usse oopar hain. Yaani agar main apne dogs ko bachpan se agar daalna chahta toh main yahan par hamesha unko leash par lekar jaata.
Toh jaise hi wo khargosh ki taraf bhaagna start karte, main unko leash se rokta. Is tareeqe se uski instincts se main bachpan se lagaataar, bachpan mein instincts ki intensity bahut low hoti hai. Jaise-jaise badhne lag jaate hain wo amplified hone lag jaati hai because dog ki power increase ho rahi hoti hai.
Wo puppy, puppy dekha. Puppy koi bhi hilti hui cheez, ball ko kyon pakadte hain?
That's a prey drive. That's a prey drive. Kyon koi bhi cheez unke taraf, unse door jaati hai toh uski taraf bhaagte hain. Ye unka instinct hai. Toh street dogs kyon bhaagte hain? Chasing ka again usse door ja rahi hoti hai. Unki taraf aa rahe hote hain toh unka instinct kya hota hai? Isko challenge karna.
Okay, so ye cheez sab unki instincts mein aate hain. Hum unko rok sakte hain lekin wo instincts ki intensity par plus hamaari skill par plus hamaara dog ke saath bond kaisa uske oopar. Sab kuch combination mein matter karta hai. Okay.
Kashish
Okay so means instinct sabse oopar baithte hain isiliye aapne ye.
Sunny
Instincts, yeah instincts is the top jo drive karta hai. Instinct is the first matlab instinct se hi har cheez drive karta hai. Instinct ki intensity zyada hai, hamaari habit, hamaari repetition kam, kam hai. Aapki baat kuch bhi maayne nahin karti, matter hi nahin karti.
Okay.
Kashish
Even after repetition har cheez ka chal raha hai kyonki ab hum log ye ab samajh rahe hain. Phir bhi toh agar hamaara ek bahut instinctive dog hai jo har dog ka alag tareeqe ka ho sakta hai toh matlab thoda watch out karke chalna chahiye, right? lightly lena nahin lena chahiye.
Sunny
Haan bilkul, bilkul bhi nahin lena chahiye. Bilkul bhi nahin lena chahiye. So for example maine, mujhse galti hui thi na.
Kashish
Right.
Sunny
Ye puppies ke saath.
Kashish
Right.
Sunny
Haan na puppies ke saath, mujhse galti hui na. So that's wo meri, meri galti thi. Maine, maine dekh liya ki wo mere saamne kuch bhi nahin kar rahe aur maine soch liya ki wo kuch bhi nahin karenge. That was my mistake aur main darwaaza khula chhod gaya. Aur darwaaza khula chhod diya, koi bhi nahin bacha.
That was my mistake na.
Prafull
Kya hua tha?
Sunny
Puppies born hue the aur doosre dog ne unko puppies ko kill kar diya tha. Ye hua tha.
So that was bloodbath man. That was very huge thing. Yeah. So, so that's wo galti thi and humein hamesha wo instincts ko humein hamesha matter dena chahiye. Matlab it's like priority dena chahiye ki dude this is instincts.
Hum usko aise lenient nahi le sakte ki haan bhai hum bahar ja rahe hain aur humein pata hai ki wo koi dog ho gaya kisi ka yaar abhi haal filhaal hi aaya tha, hiran ke peeche bhaag gaya kyunki wo off leash rehte the. Off leash rehte the. Toh wo, wo bhaag gaya hiran ke peeche.
Ab jo human tha wo itna fast nahi tha ki uske peeche bhaag sake. Toh wo bhaag gaya aur wo dog bhi nayi jagah tha. Usko bhi nahi pata tha ki waapas kaise aana hai. Wo waapas hi nahi aa paaya. Ab pata nahi mujhe mila ya nahi mila. Lekin it's a big thing na. It's a big thing na. Yes Prafull ji.
Prafull
Hi.
Sunny
Yes.
Prafull
Do baat hai. Pehla ki agar ek nervous dog ko walk karaya ja raha hai toh familiar area mein walk karana aur har roz naye-naye area mein lekar jaana kaun sa zyada beneficial hai?
Sunny
Wo dog to dog depend karta hai. Start karte hain familiar waalon se. So agar familiar mein wo comfortable ho gaya hai, aapko 100, aapko 80%, 90% aapko achha lag raha hai ki ab 80%, 90% ho gaya toh hum thoda challenge badhaate hain.
Kyunki jab challenge badhta hai na toh jo 80-90% pehle waala tha wo phir 100 ho jaata hai. Lekin humein dog ko familiar waali place pe 80-90% pe lekar jaana hota hai calmly. Agar wo wahin par hi calm nahi hai toh phir usko kayi nayi jagah pe le jaana mushkil hoga.
Lekin ek aur yahan par wo hai, for example aapka dog darta hai lekin aap usko nature mein lekar kahin socialize karaane, hai na, jahan pe dar nahi raha, jahan pe thoda khul raha hai, wo usko plus point dega.
So dog agar kisi nayi jagah pe ja raha hai, wahan par uska environment ya phir wahan par uska behavior ya phir wahan par jo uska poora association hai wo kaisi hai? Wo bhi, wo bhi matter karti hai. So ek clear answer nahi de sakta main is jagah par. First kyun, kyun clear answer nahi de sakta?
First of all ye dog pe bhi depend karta hai. Aap usko nayi area mein lekar ja rahe ho toh dog actual mein abhi uska behavior kaisa hai, uska context kaisa hai, wo abhi familiar place pe kaise, kaise behave karta hai. Doosra, jo handler hai wo kaise kar raha hai.
Teesri, jo aap kahin nayi jagah lekar ja rahe ho, wahan par uska kya experience hai, wo bhi matter karta hai. So every jagah par, har jagah hum agar ek nervous hain, insecure hain toh jo usko familiar pe hum pehle comfortable rakhte hain.
Ek baar familiar pe wo halka comfortable hone lagta hai toh hum challenge increase karte hain.
Challenge mein agar ghabrahat zyada ho rahi hoti hai toh challenges hum kam karte hain. Ghabrahat kam ho rahi hoti hai toh challenges hum increase aur badhaane lag jaate hain. So dog ki pace pe depend karta hai. So hum step by step usko aise aage lekar jaate hain.
Not koi strategy any but lekin hum usko challenges zaroor dete hain grow hone ke liye, uske pace par.
Prafull
I was reading somewhere ki dog ko familiar jagah par baar-baar wahin pe usi routine mein walk karaya jaaye.
Sunny
Yeah.
Prafull
So sort of ek map bana lete hain dog- Yeah, yeah, yeah. So they know is corner pe tension aane waali hai leash pe they already are tense, they are preempting it after some- Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Sunny
So see that's a, that's a completely different thing.
Prafull
Yeah.
Sunny
That's a completely, uh, that's a completely different thing.
Wo wahan par kya, wahan par kya ho raha hai na aap jo handler hai na usko bhi thodi sahooliyat provide kar rahe ho. Kyunki sirf dog tense nahi hota wahan par, us mod par. Getting my point? Sirf, sirf dog kyunki wo human ki bhi habit ban chuki hai us mod ke oopar.
So us mod ke, ho sakta hai ki us dog ko koi aur human lekar jaaye toh dog kuch kaise bhi waisa behave hi nahi kare, jaisa behave karte aaya. Lekin agar aap same hi human ja raha hai toh us human ki habit bhi toh ban chuki hai ki wo mod aayega aur human bhi toh tense ho jaayega.
Wo mod aayega, wo dog aayega toh human bhi toh tense ho jaayega. Toh phir jab hum nayi jagah le jaane ke liye bolte hain toh wo human ke liye bhi nayi hoti, wo dog ke liye bhi nayi hoti. Then phir wo scratch se start karte hain.
Lekin phir agar human ka behavior hai ki koi bhi dog se wo tense ho jaata hai toh wahan par bhi fail ho jaaoge. Okay, so it's, it's, it's not completely about the dog.
It's about the ha- isliye maine aapko pehle bola dog pe bhi depend karta hai, jo handler hai us pe bhi depend karta hai aur dog ka kya experience hai present waale par aur aane waale par, us pe bhi depend karta hai. So it's completely depend case to case.
Lekin dog ko mauka dena chahiye aur human ko mauka dena chahiye grow hone ke liye. So agar wo ek hi tareeqe ke ro-route pe ja rahe hain aur wo route ab boreiat ho gaya hai aur aapki grow nahi ho pa rahi hai wahan se, kisi tareeqe se wahan par stuck feel ho raha hai.
Bhale wo reaction mein stuck feel ho raha hai, lekin aapko stuck feel ho raha hai, try something new. Try something. Zyada se zyada, zyada se zyada kya hoga? Like, like dog aur thoda ghabraayega then phir ek back step le lena. Par ho sakta hai ki kuch wo mil jaaye, hai na? Kuch raasta mil jaaye.
So try something new that, that time. Okay, jab stuck feel ho raha hai.
Prafull
Yeah.
Sunny
Okay.
Prafull
The second question is about trigger stacking jo aapke module two mein towards the end...
Sunny
Okay.
Prafull
So, uh, agar if on a walk, for a prolonged walk usmein ek ke baad ek, ek ke baad ek trigger aate ja rahe hain.
Sunny
Yeah.
Prafull
Aur, uh, the body is not able to release that kyunki uska central nervous system jo hai it is getting activated more and more and more aur uska threshold oopar- More and more.
Sunny
More and more.
Prafull
So, uh, what is the right way to calm down the central nervous system?
Sunny
Oh yeah. So, so ye cheez, ye cheez dekho maine pehle bhi cover kari thi khaaskar ek panic dog ke saath. I think aap logon ke saath share, shaayad I don't know. So ek panic dog ke saath kaise behave karna chahiye.
Wo aapko complete picture de deta hai is cheez ka. Kyunki dekho jo ek panic dog hota hai na, wo jitna stack karta hai na utna koi stack nahi karta. Jo triggers hote hain stack, suppose kar lo humare paas ek reactive dog hai. Toh uska stacking itna, stacking matlab wo baar-baar kisi tareeqe se jhalla raha hai. Hai na?
Kisi tareeqe se wo uncomfortable ho raha hai. Kisi tareeqe se wo ek unfamiliar zone mein ja raha hai aur kisi tareeqe se wo ek out of balance ho raha hai. Wo usko stacking ka matlab samajhte hain. Baaki log jitne bhi log hai na stacking ka matlab samajhte hain toh wo stacking kar raha hai.
Ab ek jo dog panic hota hai, wo jitna stack karta hai na utna koi bhi dog nahi kar sakta. Kyun? Kyunki wo har ek moment pe stack kar raha hota hai. So un do-us dog ke saath jab aap work karte ho na, ye saare ke saare stacking aapko bachhe lagte hain.
Toh wo kaise work karte hain un dog ke, un dog ke saath hum kaise work karte hain?
Jaise hi wo dog panic hone lagta hai, hum apna movement band kar dete hain. Complete stop. Hum complete ek jagah par khade ho jaate hain. Kyon? Ab wo stacking aage nahi badh sake. Wo wahin par stop ho jaaye. So wo stacking aayi bhi hai. Ab wo usko release karne wala hai. Aur release kaise karega?
Barking, yapping, snapping, idhar jaayega, udhar jaayega, aise karega. Toh hum usko kya karte hain? Usko hum wahin par shaanti se baithaate hain. Okay, hum usko wahin par shaanti se baithaate hain. Jab wo shaanti se baithta hai tab hum ek doosri step lete hain. Toh is tareeqe se hum aise dog ke saath work karte hain.
Hum silence lete hain, hum ek stop lete hain. Toh bhale ab wo insecure dog ho, bhale wo ek anxious dog ho, bhale wo ek reactive dog ho. Usne react kiya, idhar-udhar kiya, hum direct aage nahi badhte. Usko baithaate hain, khud ko shaant karte hain aur phir thoda break lete hain aur phir aage badhte hain, relax karke.
Toh dog bhi settle ho paata hai aur hum bhi settle ho paate hain. Ye right approach hoti hai dog ke saath is tareeqe ke behaviors mein.
Prafull
Jab ek dog triggered hai toh usko ek jagah par bithaana, won't it unsettle him more? Aur usko thoda ghuma-phira kar, so what is the right approach?
Sunny
So wahi again, again dekho ab dog trigger kis liye hua? Agar dog suppose kar lo saamne waale ke ek dog ki taraf se trigger hua. Okay, kisi dog ki, kisi dog ki taraf se trigger hua. Toh agar jab hum usko baithaenge toh hum uski peeth de ke udhar ki taraf baithaenge.
Uski peeth us dog ki taraf hai jisne trigger kiya usko. Getting my point? Uski peeth us taraf hai. Aur wo aap kaise baithaoge kis par depend karta hai? Handler ke upar. So it's not ki wo completely dog ke upar poori ki poori cheez strategy...
Suppose kar lo handler wo nahi hai. Uh, is cheez mein abhi skillful nahi hai. Toh hum usko kya bolenge? Halka-halka uska munh idhar karke aage badhte ja. Lekin as a behaviorist agar ek skillful jaayega toh hum usko kya bolenge? Apni kamar usko dikha. Apne dog ko bol ki wo apni kamar dikhaaye.
Toh yaani aap dog ko kya bol rahe ho? Jab bhi kuch aisa trigger aaye, tu usko ignore kar. Okay, ignore kar. Peeth dikhaane ka matlab kya hota hai? Ignore kar. Toh hum leash se usko bata rahe hain tu ignore kar. Over a period time kya hoga? Uski aadat kya hogi? Wo apna munh pherne lag jaayega.
Lekin over a period time hota hai wo. Wo apna munh, usko samajh mein aa jaaye, samajh mein aa jaata hai iske saath lunging se achha hai ki main munh hi udhar pher loon. Wo zyaada shaanti wala hai. So dog balance ki taraf bhaagte hain.
Naturally unko balance chahiye hota hai. Calmness chahiye hoti hai, ek stability chahiye hoti hai. Lekin wo unko pata nahi hota wo kaise achieve karni hai. So that's, that's hum unko sikha sakte hain. Agar, agar aapki skill nahi hai, abhi skill develop kar rahe ho, so sirf dog ka munh udhar rakhna hota hai.
Us dog ki taraf nahi karna hota aur aap seedha aage chal sakte ho. Lekin agar aapki skill hai toh dog ko unki taraf le jaakar phir uska munh idhar kar kar aur phir usko shaanti se neeche baitha sakte. Ye skill matlab aise develop kar sakte ho ye skill.
Toh phir dog ko samajh mein aata hai achha, hum usmein bhi kya sikha rahe the avoid. Lekin ismein emotions zyaada hai. Wahaan par baithaane mein emotion ki intensity zyaada hai. So emotion ki jab intensity zyaada hai toh hum isko kahaan par divert kar rahe hain?
Towards an association aur wo association kya hai? Avoidance of the dog. Okay, avoidance of. Toh baithaane mein intensity zyaada hai aur ismein skill zyaada lagti hai human ki. Jo handler hai, jo leash se handle kar raha hai. Hai na? Toh uski skill zyaada lagti hai. Kyunki ismein intensity zyaada hai na.
So that's how you, you do it.
Prafull
It just happened with me day before yesterday. Toh main walk kar raha tha. Toh ek ke baad ek it kept happening. Toh mere saamne wo trigger stacking ka poora chapter dikh raha tha.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
Got out, there was a cat in front of Kulpee.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
So he started chasing. Rok liya. Theek hai.
Sunny
Baitha tha wo.
Prafull
Alert ho gaya, haan. Tab usko- baitha. Cat ran away. Toh wo ho gaya. Uske baad we went ahead. Wahaan ek football padi hui thi. Pata nahi kis bachhe ki thi.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
He went after that. He started playing with, wo gaya aage roll hua, toh he went running uske aage.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
I stopped him again. Toh wahaan wo aur zyaada wo ho gaya. Aage gaye.
Sunny
Stack ho gaya.
Prafull
Bachhe khel rahe the cycle pe.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
And they were pushing towards him kuch tezi se hi.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
Toh aur zyaada unse trigger ho gaya.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
Aage wahaan pe group of kids were playing amongst each other. Wo chillam chilli kar rahe the bahut.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
Ye chaar-paanch cheezein hui. Then maine bola ki ho gaya, ab thoda rukna chahiye. Then I just- pehle baar mein rukna chahiye tha.
Sunny
Haan, pehli baar mein.
Prafull
Main ruka, lekin zyaada time tak nahi ruka. Mujhe laga ki chalo theek hai, ho jaayega. Aage ka trigger kisko pata tha?
Sunny
Nahi, main bataata hoon. Aise main bataata hoon aapko. Jaise jab bhi kuch aisa ho na, you start, aapko ek cheez bataaoon. Hamaare andar humein tension feel hogi, like in chest.
If you focus on yourself, agar aapka dog is tareeqe se behave karega aapke haath se lekar hai na, you will feel some heaviness kind of thing here. Hai na? Tab toh wo aapko samajh mein aayega ki abhi hum aage nahi badh sakte.
Prafull
Correct.
Sunny
That is, that is tension traveling through leash to you ki hum abhi aage nahi badh sakte. So you will breathe aur wo tension release karoge. Ab wo lekin wo aapki tension nahi hai. Wo aapke dog ki tension hai jo aap feel kar rahe ho. Hai na? So aap wo release, wo breathe karoge aur release karoge us cheez ko.
Phir aapko light feel hoga, then you move ahead. Warna wahin khade raho. Wo more troubling, wo more exercise wali hai dog, dog ke liye. Wo mental thakaane wali hai. Agar aap jab wahin khade rehte ho, wo more thakta hai usse. Hai na? Toh phir hum aage, phir hum aage badhenge. Toh dog phir stack nahi karta.
Otherwise wo, jo aap bol rahe ho waisa hi hota hai phir.
Prafull
Ultimately hum log ruke ek jagah par. Uh, aur coincidentally maine wahi kiya jo aap abhi just bata rahe the ki I just made him turn around, sit, matlab away from the triggers.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
And he sat down for some time. Phir uske baad, pehle wo hyperventilate type breathe kar raha tha.
Sunny
Haan.
Prafull
Ekdam aur jhidak tha. And then I saw him calm down slowly thoda-thoda-thoda.
Sunny
Yes.
Prafull
Then once he was in a state where he was listening to me, uske baad he started walking and I then made him run thoda sa nervous energy release karne ke liye.
Sunny
Haan, yes.
Prafull
Uske baad theek ho gaya.
Sunny
That's it. Yehi tha. See, see aapne kiya wahi, lekin thode like- Link thode. Lessons, lessons ke aapko achhe lessons mile wahaan se.
Prafull
Yeah.
Sunny
Hai na? Kaise work kar, actually aapko real life scenario mila ki stacking kaise work karta hai. So that's how se-real mein stacking aise work karta hai aur humein aise break karna hota hai.
Aur wo break first step mein hi karte ho toh sabse easy rehta hai. Baaki sab cheezein nahi, nahi hoti hai. But stacking is real. Panic dog mein sabse zyada hota hai. Aur panic dog ke saath aap sabse zyada seekhte ho.
Ek baar aap panic dog ke saath seekh gaye na, kaise usko release karna hai, uske, phir aap kisi bhi dog ke saath kar sakte ho. Phir kya hai ki humein na, a, time ka frustration nahi hota. Panic dog sabse zyada time leta hai aage badhne mein.
Ek-ek-ek insecure dog ya ek frustrated dog ho ek ya phir triggered dog, wo itna time nahi lega jitna ek panic dog time lega calm down hone mein. Toh human ko wahan par time dena hota hai. Seedha khada hona hota hai. Jab tak wo shaant nahi ho jaaye, no talk, nothing. Kayi baar 10 minute lag jaate hain.
10 minute mein hum ek hi jagah par khade hue hain. Maine aise-aise panic dogs handle kiye hain, humein 10 minute tak main ek hi jagah par khada hua.
Main move nahi ho raha, apni body ka koi bhi part move nahi kar raha. Phir wo shaant hua, phir main aage badha. But results achhe hain na? Wo 10 minute mein wo result achhe hain na? Wo dog phir aage panic hi nahi hua. Wo complete change ho gaya. Wo sirf 10 minute wait karne se.
So work karta hai stacking ko agar hum break kar dete hain shuruat mein. Okay, guys? So that's it, guys aaj ke liye. Kisi aur ke koi sawaal toh nahi hai? Thank you so much. I think so. Aur exams aa rahe hain. Abhi kuch-kuch logon ne apne slots book kar liye hain.
Please apne slot book kar lijiye aur jo naye batch ke hain, batch two hai, please study ja-jaari rakhiye. Aur maine kuch hamara resource kaun sa topic hai? Resource karke topic hai community ke andar. Usmein bahut saari PDF share hai.
Aap usmein nutrition ki bhi PDF share hai aur uske andar behavior ki bhi PDF share hai.
Completely har cheez free hai uske andar. Aap usmein download kar sakte ho apne interest ke mutabiq aur padh sakte ho. Aur sawaal pooch sakte ho community ke andar, completely welcome hai. Yeh sabke liye hai. So wo read karo, bahut knowledge milegi. Bahut distilled information hai uske andar.
Like multiple cheezein padhne ke baad kuch checkpoints mein humne, maine poora distill karke nikaala hai. It will help you. Phir aap aur deeply ja sakte ho cheezon ke andar. But start reading, start jab bhi aapko time mile, is par time nikaalo and start reading, dogs ke baare mein samajhna chahte ho toh.
And that's it aaj ke liye itna. Ek Kashish, tumhaare kuch sawaal hain?
Kashish
Jee, toh sorry, aapne jo slots open kiye hain chaar din ke hain, toh would it be okay se next week ka aap open karoge?
Sunny
Yeah, unke baad open karunga. Haan, unke baad open karunga, but unke baad open karunga. Ya abhi open kar dein? Main kar deta hoon. Main abhi open kar deta hoon.
Kuch fark toh maine kal chaar hi open kar rahe the par main open kar dunga saare. Parth bhi pooch raha tha. Yes Parth main open kar dunga August tak. August toh chal hi raha hai yaar. August ke end tak saare open kar denge. Phir uske baad bhi chahiye hoga toh we will open but slot book kar lo as early as possible.
Okay.
Kashish
And jo module two ke hain maine lessons readout poore kar liye. I have not written them whole down. Agar ek aadha reh jaata hai toh ho ja, chal jaayega ki.
Sunny
Haan koi, yeah, yeah matlab, yeah matlab like tumhe basically wahan par case studies hain aur case studies se zyada main abhi theory pe, haan case studies se zyada main abhi theory pe focus kar raha hoon tum, tum logon ke saath ki tumhe theoretically poori knowledge ho and then uske baad phir main case studies ke upar aaunga.
So theoretically jo tumhaare cases ki tumhaare paas knowledge hai, issues ki tumhaare paas knowledge hai that is enough and usse actually evaluation hai.
Main tumhe kis direction mein lekar jaana hai, kaise direction mein lekar jaana hai taaki tumhari growth aur achhi ho aur tum deeply understand kar sako. Toh uske liye mujhe tumhara bhi present mindset toh samajh mein aana chahiye na. Tumhara present mindset kaisa hai dog ko lekar, unke behavior ko lekar.
Aur wo kab aayega? When we go on one to one evaluation. Uske bina kaise aayega? Possible nahi hai na. Theek hai. So guys padhai karo aur- Sir exam ka pattern.
Speaker 6
Sorry exam ka pattern kya hai Sunny? Multiple option type question honge ya humein answers likhne hain.
Sunny
Just ba, just baatein, discussion. Just discussion.
Speaker 6
Exam mentality.
Sunny
Just like viva. Viva right?
Speaker 6
Haan, just like viva man. Yeh bhai ekdam college le gaya mann ko.
Poora viva, viva, viva, viva. Cool hai. Cool hai man.
Sunny
Maine apna get up hi college wala kar liya Sunny ab exam aa raha hai. Cool hai man. So milte hain waapas se aur community mein active rehte hain. Yahan par agar toofaan-uufaan aaya toh meri activity thodi low ho jaati hai and baahar ka dekhna hota hai cheezein mujhe.
Toh isliye activity aur abhi kuch time aur chalegi yaar kyunki abhi ekdam sahi hai. Lekin ekdam hi baadal kahin se aa jaate hain aur hawa tez chaalu ho jaati hai, ped gir jaate hain, bijli gaayab ho jaati hai. Sab kuch sahi chalta-chalta hai.
Toh kuch time aisa chalega then I will be more active but tab tak ke liye please handle and let me know koi bhi aapke sawaal hai community mein poochte rahiye. Okay, that's it. Okay.
Kashish
Okay.
Sunny
Bye, bye.
Speaker 6
Thank you. Good night.
Sunny
Yeah good night. Bye everyone. Good night.
Kashish
See you.
More calls on behavioural
Sat 26 Sep 2026
1 hr 44 min
Canine mind basics, breed traits and bringing a dog home in India
Two Pro program members, Paresh and Reena, led their first practice sessions for the group, with Sunny Luthra facilitating and giving feedback. Paresh explained how to read a dog through three layers, the animal, the breed, and the individual personality, while Reena covered the practical, financial, and emotional commitments of bringing a dog home in India. The long Q&A that followed used real cases (pacing after walks, tail biting, nipping at legs, a bored Labrador) to show how to gather data before concluding on a dog's behaviour, and closed with an extended, unresolved group debate on ethical breeding versus adoption. Sunny also outlined plans to build member web pages using clips from these evaluation sessions.
12 chapters · 9 member questions · puppy care, adoption, training, behavioural
Sun 19 Jul 2026
1 hr 20 min
Building Dog Confidence Through Skills, Water and Agility
Sunny Luthra led a discussion on how confidence is built through skill development rather than delusion, in both dogs and humans, using agility, swimming, and daily obstacle exposure as tools. Members shared personal stories of overcoming fear (claustrophobia, water phobia, mountaineering) and connected these to how owner anxiety transfers to dogs through energy and behavior. The call also covered puppy separation anxiety training, collar sensitivity, reading tail and body language during dog greetings, and redirecting reactive dogs using leash timing, plus a case study on resolving a lift-biting incident with a housing society.
12 chapters · 7 member questions · training, behavioural, psychology, body language
Sat 19 Sep 2026
1 hr 31 min
Reading dog and human energy: a biting Indie case study
The call opened with a member sharing how her dog's recurring UTIs were traced back to absorbing her husband's stress energy, leading into a discussion on how sensitive dogs absorb human emotions. Sunny then ran a live case study exercise about a three year old Indie who bites and attacks guests and other dogs on walks, guiding members to ask better diagnostic questions. The group learned that they were jumping to conclusions about the situation instead of first gathering information about the dog and the human as individual entities, and that the real root cause was the male owner's chronic tension being absorbed and reflected by the dog. The session closed with an explanation of Wim Hof breathing and meditation as tools to regulate human emotional baseline, which is what actually resolved the case, plus a preview of how to communicate this kind of feedback to clients.
12 chapters · 12 member questions · case study, aggression, reactivity, leash handling